Monday, December 05, 2016

MMGM- Fannie Never Flinched: One Woman’s Courage in the Struggle for American Labor Union Rights



It's Marvelous Middle Grade Monday at Ramblings of a Wannabe Scribe and What Are You Reading? day at Teach Mentor Texts and Unleashing Readers. It's also Nonfiction Monday.



28818218Farrell, Mary Cronk. Fannie Fannie Never Flinched: One Woman’s Courage in the Struggle for American Labor Union Rights 
November 1st 2016 by Abrams Books for Young Readers
Copy provided by Young Adult Books Central

Fannie Sellins was a single mother trying to put food on the table for her four young children by working in Marx and Haas Clothing Co. in St. Louis. The conditions were wretchedly poor, so when she heard about seamstresses in Chicago and New York City forming unions, she rallied support from the workers to create Local 67 of the United Garment Workers of America. Although the conditions were improved at this factory, it was still a very difficult way to earn a living. 


After serving as president of her local union, Fannie traveled to different cities giving talks about working conditions. In the early 1900s, these were often treacherous-- buildings in poor condition, workers riddled with disease, and dangerous jobs performed by very young children. The union not only worked to get these conditions improved, but took up collections to help families affected by them. Strikes were common and often brutal. At one of these, in Black Valley, Pennsylvania, shots were fired into a crowd, and Fannie was killed. The police inquiry absolved the officer, and even commended the force for keeping the peace!


While young readers may study a little bit about the labor movement in the United States, it is often impersonal. Focusing a movement around the actions of one person is a great way to encourage empathy for it by giving it a human face. 


The formatting of this book is excellent-- while I'm not usually a fan of larger books (this is about 10" x 10"), this size allows plenty of photographs and a lot of space around the text. While it may seem silly, this is a HUGE selling point. Readers are often reluctant to pick up books filled with dense blocks of text and few pictures. The buttons and cogs at the bottom of the sepia toned pages also make this a more reader-friendly book, and that will go a long way to entice children to read about this important historical figure. 


I loved this author's Pure Grit, but felt that it was too long and involved for most of my readers. Fannie Never Flinched struck an excellent balance between easy-to-read format and amount of information. It's a great starting point for National History Day projects (especially in 2016-17, with the theme being Taking a Stand!), and will intrigue and encourage readers to investigate the other sources listed in the bibliography. 



28114551Reef, Catherine. Florence Nightingale: The Courageous Life of a Legendary Nurse.
November 8th 2016 by Clarion Books
Library copy

We're going to chalk this one up to a bad evening. I love biographies, I love stories of strong, influential women, and I think this book has a lot going for it. I just couldn't get into it. 

The good side: I was impressed by the number of pictures and illustrations this one had. I think these are important for students, because it both engages and informs them. When dealing with the 1800s, there are often few illustrations that can be used. This is clearly well researched, and I am definitely ordering a copy because (oddly) I don't have a book about Florence Nightingale, and this is a very solid biography.

The down side: This read more like an adult book. Instead of giving just the essentials, it had frequent digressions into relatives like "Mad" Peter, Florence being in a "torpor" in Egypt, and other things that weren't really useful for history projects or interesting. Since I once read an almost 400 page book on Cadbury chocolate (Chocolate Wars), I'm going to attribute my disengagement up to a bad evening. Everyone else seemed to really like this one. 

9 comments:

  1. Thanks for this review -- I've been wondering about its readability for middle grades. I'm glad you're always honest!

    Amanda @ A Bookshelf Monstrosity

    ReplyDelete
  2. I always appreciate your thorough and honest reviews. And as for Florence Nightingale, I am always surprised publishers see a need for ANOTHER book about her life, but I promise to try it if I get the chance. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love biographies about important women. I keep seeing "Fannie Never Flinched" reviewed by others and must get my copy to read. Thanks for the great reviews.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks so much for featuring FANNIE NEVER FLINCHED. I've already talked with two groups of students from Pennsylvania have chosen Fannie Sellins for the National History Day Projects!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really like Fannie Never Flinched; a brave woman whose story has been untold for too long! Thanks for reviewing!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Both of these look like really interesting entries for non-fiction readers. I just have such a problem getting into non-fiction and I've been that way since I was kid. I'm not sure why. But thanks for your great reviews though as always. They give me some good ideas for potential books to put in our children's area.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love middle grade books that celebrate the lives of courageous women - thanks for sharing these titles.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Fannie looks like one I'd enjoy. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous5:59 PM EDT

    Fannie inspires me because she was focused and single-minded and courageous for disadvantaged people.

    ReplyDelete