The Kicks- Hat Trick/ Anna Banana and the Monkey in the Middle

Morgan, Alex. Hat Trick (The Kicks #4)
June 2nd 2015 by Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers

Devin is unhappy that soccer season is over, but she and several of her teammates discover that there are try outs for winter soccer. Emma doesn't make the team, and Frida is off making a movie with teen hottie Brady McCoy. Jessi makes the Griffons with Devin, although Zoe is on the Gators. Also on the Griffons-- the mean Mirabelle, with whom Devin has made a sort of peace, but also the even more evil Jamie. To top it off, Coach Darby encourages aggressive play, which leads to bruises for Jessi and a first ever yellow card for Devin. It could be worse, though-- Devin's younger sister Maisie isn't playing soccer at all, because the school funding for her team has been cut. The girls from the Kicks, as well as some from the Griffons, band together to have a big fundraiser so that the elementary team can stay in place and have everything from an eco-friendly carwash to a bake sale to a skills camp for younger players. A surprise guest makes the day and raises enough money to save the team.
Strengths: It's great to see a book where characters have passions that drive them to do things. Devin's "hat trick" refers to the three things she wants to accomplish. It's a happy book with supportive parents but small problems that are dealt with in a constructive fashion. Plus, there's lots of soccer action!
Weaknesses: Frida being a movie actress seemed a bit far fetched, and I'm not sure that a fund raiser could really save a school soccer team.
What I really think: This is a great series that my soccer playing girls adore. They are quick, have bright, appealing covers, a celebrity author who really knows her sport, and are just fun!


Rissi, Anica Mrose. Anna Banana and the Monkey in the Middle (#2)
July 7th 2015 by Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
E ARC from Edelweiss Above the Treeline

Anna is back after Anna Banana and the Friendship Split. She has mended things with Sadie, and the two girls are now fast friends with Isabel. When their third grade class is taking a trip to the zoo, Anna feels pulled between the two. Only two girls can sit in one bus seat, so Anna has to agree to sit with one girl going to the zoo and the other coming back. Luckily, at the zoo, they are allowed to be in a group of three. They have to decide what animal to do a report on when they return to school-- Anna would like to do pandas, but the group decides to do crocodiles so there are no favorites. This stresses Anna out, and when she gets home, her father suggests she write each of her friends a letter saying why they are each her "favorite Sadie" or "favorite Isabel", and invite them both over for a sleepover. Anna's brother is a little stressed about his math test as well, but their parents (a stay-at-home romance novelist father and high powered corporate executive mother) are supportive and catch up with them during their family dinners.
Strengths: This was spot-on with third grade friend drama, and addressed it in a very productive way. I also liked that the class went to the zoo and was doing an animal report, since that is something that most third or fourth graders actually do. Banana is adorable, the family dynamics are good; I really enjoy these. Liked this one even better than the first, since Sadie was unaccountably evil in the first one!
Weaknesses: Love the diversity on the cover, but still wish I knew a little more about the ethnicity of the characters. In the E ARC, the pictures don't show it as clearly. Glad that the story isn't about the ethnicity, since it will appeal to all manner of elementary school readers.
What I really think: I want one just like this but set in middle school, with middle school problems!


Book three comes out in September, and book four, Anna Banana and the Puppy Parade, comes out in January.

Like Anne Warren Smith's Turkey Monster Thanksgiving series, these have adorable covers and are such fun, but I have to stop reading them! You can tell that when I was in third grade, this would have been exactly the sort of book that I would have read!

Guy Friday- Old Wolf

Avi and Floca, Brian. Old Wolf
August 4th 2015 by Atheneum/Richard Jackson Books
E ARC from Edelweiss Above the Treeline

Casey's 13th birthday is exciting-- he gets a book on bow hunting from his parents, and a special dinner is planned for that night, but his father is detained because of the spring snow. At the same time, things are rough for the leader of a wolf pack, Nashoba. He is challenged by a younger wolf, who bites his paw after Nashoba cannot find food for the pack. Nashoba manages to make friends with a Raven, Merla, who brings Nashoba food in exchange for a favor: there is a herd of elk without the bulls, and Merla would like the wolf pack to take down a couple and leave the flock some leftovers. Nashoba finds the herd and returns to tell the pack, but when the pack attacks, things go wrong and Nashoba is gravely injured. The next day, Casey goes out with his new bow and attempts to reenact the bow shooting video game that he has. He shoots and kills something and feels bad about it, but he also finds Nashoba and tries to help the wolf, getting himself attacked after putting ointment on the wolf's paw. Nashoba escapes, and Casey never plays his video game again.
Strengths: Wolves are one animal that students frequently want to read about, and there are not too many books. This is a short book, with plentiful illustrations, and so might be good for elementary schools or reluctant middle school readers who want an adventure story with hunting. Both parents are alive, and very supportive. The video game tie-in might appeal to some readers.
Weaknesses: This does have some violence, both between the animals, and with Casey shooting, and there didn't seem to be much of a plot.
What I really think: Not sure what the purpose of this one was. Avi is really hit or miss for me. Enjoyed Catch You Later, Traitor, and one of my older daughter's favorite books is The Good Dog, but I got to the end of this and wasn't quite sure what was supposed to have been conveyed.

Pool Party Puzzler (Nancy Drew Clue Book #1)/ Ruby on the Outside

Keene, Carolyn. Pool Party Puzzler (Nancy Drew Clue Book #1)
July 7th 2015 by Aladdin
E ARC from Edelweiss Above the Treeline

Nancy, George and Bess are helping out George's mother, who is catering a Sweet Half 16 party for the 8-year-old diva, Deidre. Not only is the event catered, but there is real white sand by the pool, topiary bushes sculpted by Taffy, and a lavender scooter as a present. Everyone has been invited to the party but Shelby. The party goes well until Marissa the mermaid shows up to do a swim show, but there is a snake at the bottom of the pool! The snake turns out to be a fake, and even Deidre tells Nancy not to worry about investigating who put it there, but the Clue Crew is not to be dissuaded. They investigate everyone from the waiters from a local restaurant who were serving, to Taffy, to Shelby, who had attended the party in a costume but was discovered by Nancy because of her pink nail polish. After visiting the joke shop where the snakes were purchased, Nancy figures out who put the snake in the pool... and why.
Strengths: This was a simple, fun mystery for beginning readers that had an Encyclopedia Brown type question at the end-- can you guess the mystery? (Yes, I could.)
Weaknesses: Deidre was over the top, and made the story a bit unbelievable.
What I really think: I am ridiculously enamored with these short series with pretty, bright covers (think Sew Zooey!, Hirandani's Cooking Club, The Year of the Book), but this one wasn't anything particularly fresh. The second book in this series, Last Lemonade Standing, sounds freakishly like the
1997 The Lemonade Raid (Nancy Drew: Notebooks, #19). For middle school, I prefer the Nancy Drew Diaries.

And now, I just want to do a masters thesis on the many incarnations of Nancy Drew!

Baskin, Nora Raleigh. Ruby on the Outside
June 16th 2015 by Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
Public library copy

Ruby lives in a condo complex with her aunt, whom she calls Matoo (ma, too). Her mother has been in jail since Ruby was five, and Ruby hasn't told any of her friends at school, fearing repercussions. It is the summer after fifth grade, and things are rather dull. Kristin, the only girl her age in the complex, leaves for camp, but luckily a new girl, Margalit, moves in, and the two quickly become friends. They write stories, play games, and get along very well... until Ruby discovers a secret that she thinks will tear the two apart. Ruby and her aunt visit her mother every weekend, but this secret interferes with these visits as well. Eventually, Ruby rediscovers the entire truth about why her mother is in prison, feels comfortable sharing this with her friends, and is ready to start middle school as a more understanding and developed person.
Strengths: There are very few books that address parents in prison, and it's certainly something that even middle class, suburban students deal with from time to time. The only book on the topic that I have is Calvert's Glennis, Before and After, from 1996. The circumstances seem realistic, and the details of prison and the workings of the judicial system seem well-researched. Baskin has an intriguing style. Her Anything But Typical is brilliant.
Weaknesses: Ruby does seem to think about her mother more than I would think she would after five years of living with her aunt, and the coincidence of names seemed a bit far fetched.
What I really think: I don't think this will do well with middle school students. The way the girls play in the summer, as well as the general social dynamic, seems much more elementary school. Certainly an excellent choice for elementary libraries.

River Runs Deep

Bradbury, Jennifer. River Runs Deep
July 21st 2015 by Atheneum Books for Young Readers
ARC from Baker and Taylor

In 1842, young Elias is sent to Dr. Croghan in Mammoth Cave, Kentucky, where the doctor's innovative treatments are supposed to cure his consumption. Since his father died of the ailment, Elias' mother is desperate enough to send him all the way from Virginia to live there. In small huts within the cave, the patients are kept quiet and fed restrictive diets in hope that the damp air and underground spring might effect a cure. Elias isn't happy with inactivity, and soon makes friends or a variety of patients, as well as some of the Negroes working for Dr. Croghan. Elias receives an injured carrier pigeon from Pennyrile, a mysterious patient who is not allowed to talk, and raises it. In his wanderings with Stephen, who works for Dr. Croghan, he finds that there is more going on in the caves than recuperation and the odd tourist visit.
Strengths: Interesting historical time and place to write about, interesting tie-in with other parts of history, and good descriptions of tuberculosis treatment at the time. Definitely one to pair with Invincible Microbe, and a bit more exciting than most tuberculosis stories. (And there are more of those than one would think!)
Weaknesses: Elias' immediate friendship with the Negro boys is a bit of a stretch, and readers who aren't well-versed in the history of tuberculosis treatment might need more background in order to understand this.
What I really think: I adored Bradbury's Shift, Wrapped, and A Moment Comes, but didn't connect with this one quite as much.

Stone Rider/ Thor's Serpents

Hofmeyr, David. Stone Rider
July 14th 2015 by Delacorte Press
ARC from Baker and Taylor

In a horrible, arid futuristic dystopia where the only choices seem to be working in the mines or riding in treacherous byke races, Adam Stone tries to survive. His parents are dead, and only his older brother Frank is around to help him. Frank is missing a leg, and Adam has a tendency to black out, but when Adam meets fellow rider Kane, who seems to need help, the two offer Kane shelter and some of their meager food supplies. But Adam has angered the wrong people, and soon his only option is to enter the Blackwater race and hope to win passage to the Sky-Base, where living conditions are not quite so bad. He befriends a very young rider, Nate, and finds that two of the children, Sadie and Wyatt,of a tyrannical commander who is charge of the race are also on the course. Adam thinks that the only way to survive is to be by himself, but quickly comes to rely on the help of Kane, as well as Sadie. When surprising information about his fellow racers is revealed, will this help or hurt his efforts in the race?
Strengths: This has a LOT of action and adventure, and is a great choice for readers who enjoy Earth based dystopias. The byke racing is full of pulse pounding twists and turns, and there are evil characters aplenty that made me root for Adam's survival.
Weakneses: The lack of world building moved teh story along quickly for me at first because I wanted to find out WHY there were limited choices, what had happened to the environment, who built Sky-Base, etc. Then, in the middle of the race, Adam and Sadie take a break, have a little fling, and I lost interest. This is really more YA. There are several rather gruesome deaths, the fling, and a lot of person-on-person violence. While there is nothing immediately objectionable that would keep it out of middle school, I can see younger readers being upset by it.
What I really think: Fantastic book... for high school. Think I will pass on purchase, but definitely will pass on my ARC to a freshman I know!

K.L. Armstrong, M.A. Marr. Thor's Serpents (The Blackwell Pages #3)
May 19th 2015 by Little, Brown Books for Young Readers

In this third and final book following Loki's Wolves and Odin's Ravens, Matt and his compatriots have to figure out a number of details about Ragnarok. Fen is stuck with the Raiders, who think that the end of the world will be a good thing. Laurie is upset, since Fen is the other representative of their ancestor, Loki, and she doesn't like being on opposite sides on the conflict. Matt, Owen, Baldwin et al. go to Rapid City to consult the Norns. After battling the mara (nightmares) in a museum., the Norns tell Matt that when the mythical rooster Gullinkambi crows, they must go to the battlefield, and someone in his family knows where that will be. They travel back to Blackwell via a portal where the group gets in touch with various family memebers to try to figure things out, but then they are battleing a fire giant, Jotunn, who is determined to burn down the Corn Palace! Luckily, Matt has some skills that help. There are other problems, though, including one descendant who isn't quite who the group thought she was. Matt finally locates his long lost Uncle Pete, who is a help, but it's still up to Matt to figure out what to do. Participate in Ragnarok and hope for the best, or try to find a way to make it not happen?
Strengths: There are several twists, which I don't want to give away, and the ending is not as sewn up as it is in many books. I was glad that Laurie finally had magic portals through which to transport people; saves all that weary tromping around. The mythology is nicely tied in to today's world in an innovative way, and I liked how that local landmarks are brought into the conflict.
Weaknesses: Like many fantasy books, I had to take notes to keep everything straight!
What I really think: Good covers, short series, mythology and action. Very well done. Glad to have the whole series.

MMGM- The Villain Keeper/ Lost in the Sun

McKay, Laurie. Villain Keeper (The Last Dragon Charmer #1)
February 3rd 2015 by HarperCollins
Copy provided by author

Caden, whose elder brothers have all gone on quests, is sent abruptly on one by his father, King Axel of Razzon. When he finds a dragon terrorizing a village, he is prepared to slay it, but is caught up with Brynne, a spellcaster whom he knows slightly, and is catapulted into Asheville, North Carolina! So much for achieving the status of Elite Paladin! Luckily, his gift is the gift of languages, so he is able to communicate, and Brynne's magic is helpful as well. After several days camping in the park with Caden's snow stallion, Sir Horace, the group is found by policemen. Caden tells them the truth about what he is doing in the park, and almost ends up under psychiatric care. Instead, he is sent to foster care with Rosa, and Brynne and Sir Horace escape. It's hard to transition from being a prince to being in foster care, but befriending Tito helps. What doesn't help is the fact that another foster child, Jane Chan, has gone missing, and the teachers at Caden's new school seem suspicious. The worst of the group is his math teacher, Mr. Rathis, who looks alarmingly like Rath Dunn, tyrant of the Greater Realm. He reveals himself to Caden, and Caden suspects he had something to do with Jane's disappearance. Ms. Primrose is also very odd, and Caden learns that she is really the one in charge of all of the teachers, all of whom have very dangerous ties to Razzon. Caden's quest was to slay a dragon, and he manages to find dragons to fight right in Asheville!

This was not quite the book I expected it to be, which was a very good thing. I was expecting something like Thomson's Dark Lord: The Early Years, and thought that Caden would bumble along in Asheville, make some friends, solve a mystery, and then go back to Razzon. Instead, I liked how Asheville was the "Land of Shadows" and Caden's school was housing villains from his kingdom! This gave the book a Harry Potter feeling without having any other elements of that book. The idea of a magical kingdom seeping into our world, instead of characters from our world going right into a magical kingdom, is a fresh one.

Caden manages to hold true to who he is while combating forces beyond his comprehension, but he isn't inflexible. He makes friends with Tito, and accepts that he has to be in a special education class because while he can speak many languages, he can't necessarily read them. His growing friendship with Brynne has a nice mixture of annoyance, especially when she blends in to their new setting better than he does. My favorite line was this one from Brynne (page 196) "The tech is the magic of Asheville, and I'm good at magic."

This book will appeal to a wide range of fantasy readers who enjoy everything from Cornelia Funke to Rick Riordan to Jane Yolen. There's a touch of the medieval world mixed with the realities of foster care, so Caden has to wrestle with jeans that are too long as well as savage Elderdragons! And since he is not sent back to Razzon at the end of the book, we can only hope that there will be a sequel!

It's really irritating that some books receive huge amounts of publicity and aren't really that good, while well-crafted books like this don't even make my radar unless the author contacts me personally!

It's Marvelous Middle Grade Monday at Ramblings of a Wannabe Scribe and What Are You Reading? day at Teach Mentor Texts and Unleashing Readers. It's also Nonfiction Monday.

I have to say that I was prepared to HATE the following book. Dealing with grief? Not another one. (Eyes roll entirely back into head.) I was not a fan of Absolutely Almost, mostly because of the nanny (although apparently people have them on the East coast), and A Tangle of Knots was just...weird. The print was smaller than my students like. And, ugh, right there on the cover, it says "Author of the National Book Award Nominee".

But I was wrong. This was a good book, with an authentic, middle grade voice and a realistic and not overly sad portrayal of grief. Now my only objection will be how much everyone else loves it...


Graff, Lisa. Lost in the Sun.
May 26th 2015 by Philomel Books
Copy received from Young Adult Books Central and reviewed there.

Trent is known is Cedar Lake as that kid... the kid who threw the hockey puck that killed Justin Richards. Not on purpose, but with an accidental blow that stopped his defective heart. Now, Trent is afraid to play baseball, afraid to participate in gym, alienated from his friends, and mad at his father. His father is a different issue, although Trent thinks his father only cares about himself after his comment to Trent after the accident is "Well, it happened, I guess. And there's nothing you can do about it now. No use thinking about it." (page 89. I want to have this embroidered on a pillow. The world would be a much better place if people embraced this philosophy.) He lives an hour away, but meets with Trent and his brothers Doug and Aaron for dinner, even though his new wife, Kari, is pregnant. Trent's mother is supportive, having him help at her kitchen store, checking up on him, making him get counseling in the wake of the accident. Trent even manages to make a new friend, Fallon, who is a bit Stargirl-quirky but fun to be around. Trent has supportive teachers, from Mr. Gorman in gym who doesn't make him participate but gives him other options, to the "wrinkled old crone" Ms. Emerson, who lets Trent water her plants every day and just is there for him.

Still, Trent can't pull it together. He is appalled that his brother Doug is friends with Justin's sister Annie. He manages to purposefully get a B- in every class. He's angry with his mother, won't see his father at all, and even beats up a boy who is taunting Fallon.

This is a mistake, because it makes Fallon afraid of him. Accidentally killing someone with a hockey puck is one thing; it makes Trent afraid of himself. But for Fallon to be afraid of him is unbearable.

Gently guided by the adults around him, Trent knows what he needs to do to regain her trust. He visits her father and offers to "water the plants" so that he trusts Trent. He tries to mend things with his mother, even seeking out her new boyfriend to help him with his baseball. And in a truly inspired literary moment, he sees how much his older brother, Aaron, is trying to help everyone around him, even though he is himself in danger of failing a class. All of these influences help Trent to get over his anger and frustration and begin to move on with his life.

The book is gently humorous, and has a lot of appealing scenes that move the plot forward at a good clip. Trent's obsession with baseball will attract a lot of readers to the story, if only for the list of baseball movies that he and Fallon watch. The conflict with his father is one that will resonate with middle grade readers, since issues with parents are part and parcel of middle school.

Fans of Palacio's Wonder, Buyea's Because of Mr. Terupt , Bauer's Almost Home and Jordan Sonnenblick's humorous but introspective work will feel Trent's frustration and breath a sigh of relief when he finally is able to look up and relocate everything he has Lost in the Sun.

Blather: Entering week three of four in orthopedic boot.

On the bright side, the problem the boot is solving is insignificant. Achilles tendonitis caused by overuse. When your doctor laughs when you say "But I HAVE been taking it easier!" and points out that you biked five miles to get to the office, it's a sure sign that you've just been overdoing. No long term problems, nothing serious at all.

So far, I've convinced people the injury was caused by sky diving, mountain climbing, participating in the X Games, the Tour de France and kickboxing. Much more fun to say "Mixed martial arts really IS a sport for the young" than to admit that your injury is caused by being fifty, running three miles a day, and having poor genetics.

I can drive, but my daughter got a job across town and has my car, so I get to sit at home and read all day! Might have to beg a ride to school to place a book order, but I think my principal will understand if I don't make it in. Members of staff have to swim out to the garden to tie up tomatoes for me, and doing laundry is a full day's work. Other people have to carry things up and down the stairs for me! Trying to look at this as a protracted vacation!

So why am I so grumpy today?

The Book of Dares for Lost Friends

Kelley, Jane. The Book of Dares for Lost Friends
July 14th 2015 by Feiwel & Friends
E ARC from Netgalley.com

Val and Lanora have always been best friends, but when they start junior high, Lanora (reeling from her parents' divorce) decides to "grow up" and distance herself from the fanciful Val. She straightens her hair, ditches the key chains on her backpack, and starts to hang out with the "A" crowd-- girls who are popular and whose names start with "A". Soon, they have talked Lanora into shoplifting and generally getting into trouble. Val, hoping to save her friend, finds an unlikely ally in Tasman, who works with the Captain in an odd bookshop and knows Mau, a cat whom both Val and Lanora have known. With the help of some of her new friends at school. Val tries to get Tasman to invoke a secret book to save Lanora, but he needs to find a sacred bowl to complete the spell. Will it be enough to keep Lanora from being sent to a reform school, and will anything be enough to repair the friendship?
Strengths: This had a lot of detail about life in New York City, and a lot of very true-to-life friend drama. Well written.
Weaknesses: The fantasy elements seemed out of place and... odd. Lanora is no saint, but I can see most middle school girls wanting to distance themselves from a friend like Val. The chapters revolving around the cat seemed a bit odd, too.
What I really think: Why did this bring to mind Snyder's The Egypt Game? I can't really even remember what that was about. The odd mix of adolescent drama and attempts at magic will make this a difficult book for which to find an audience in my library.

Cartoon Saturday-- Apocalypse Bow Wow

Proimos, James III.  Apocalypse Bow Wow
January 6th 2015 by Bloomsbury USA Childrens


Brownie and Apollo are sure that when they get hungry enough, their people will come home, but they don't. Knowing there is no food and water in the house, they must escape, which they do by licking a doorknob and causing a deer to jump through the window. They are totally clueless, but listen to a police dog who tells them to go to a grocery store. They are warned off by a rat, who is holed up in the store with one dog, and hopes to scare them off. Brownie and Apollo are also aided by a flea who has hopped on, and who whispers gems from Sun Tzu's Art of War in their ears. They are involved in several skirmishes, and eventually make their way home, where they seem to be preparing for a second book.
Strengths: Very simple to read notebook novel; probably only one sentence per page or less. If it had an Accelerated Reader test and I have more very low readers next year, I might buy a copy.
Weaknesses: Not much of a story, and very little to actually read.
What I really think: Much preferred Petlandia-- it would appeal to children, but I found it funny as well. This was just not as clever. 

Guy Friday- Zee's Story (Boys Camp)

Jazynka, Kitson and Tripp, Valerie. Zee's Story (Boys Camp)
May 19th 2015 by Sky Pony Press
Copy received from Young Adult Books Central and reviewed there.

Zee is thrilled to be going back to Camp Wolf Trail. He and his good friend and fellow prankster, Will, have been e mailing their plans back and forth all year. Zee is surprised when Will isn't at camp when he arrives, especially after another camper hands him a postcard-- Will isn't coming. Zee is crushed, but Will shows up under a bed and the pranks begin. They hide a plush octopus on another camper's kayak, a camp tradition which also means they get to pie the other camper in the face. They do crafts, search for the elusive diving rock, and learn kayaking skills. An overnight kayaking trip almost leads to disaster when the cook's dog, Cookie, tries to follow the boys across the lake in search of bacon. Will and Zee overcome some rough patches but enjoy their time at camp, and their campmates.

There are not many books dealing with overnight camps, especially for boys, and there are lots of interesting tips for readers who may not be familiar with the outdoor camp experience, but there is enough additional information for experienced campers, including notes at the back about a dedicated former camper who grew up to re-introduce wolves to Yellowstone National Park.

This is the third book in the series, but I was not at all confused going in without remembering the other two. A new camping season means some new characters, and old ones are reintroduced. Will and Zee have some tension in their friendship, especially since they are not assigned to the same cabin, and it is dealt with in a constructive fashion.

The large print and full color illustrations in this will appeal to slightly younger or more reluctant readers who want a solid, realistic story with a large dose of humor and enough action to keep things moving along.

The League of Beastly Dreadfuls

Grant, Holly. The League of Beastly Dreadfuls

28 April 2015, Random House Books for Young Readers
Copy received from the publisher

When Anastasia's father and hypochondriac mother are injured in a vacuum cleaner accident, she is spirited away by her "great aunties", Prim and Prudence, to their home, the former St. Agony’s Asylum for the Criminally Insane, which has somehow retained its Victorian qualities. The great aunts (who don't dress like any 80 year olds I know) keep Anastasia fed with Mysterious Lumps and make her sleep in a damp bedroom where there are horrifically scary noises. Soon, Anastasia decides to investigate on her own and comes across Quentin and Ollie, boys with special talents who are also being held hostage by the strange old ladies. Eventually, the Baron von Bilgeworth, Mouse Destroyer Extraordinaire shows up with a note from Anastasia's school librarian, Miss Apple, and Anastasia learns many things about the odd aunties, her family past, and the boys who have become her friends.
Strengths: This certainly was very well written, with clever turns of phrase, good pacing, and interesting characters. The illustrations were also unique and attractive. There was a nice twist at the end, and the series will probably go in a more interesting direction after this book, which just set the stage for Anastasia's adventures.
Weaknesses: So. Hard. To. Read. On a personal level, any book that calls me "Reader" and has that whole Lemony Snicket pretense of defining words for me makes me want to hurl it out the window. The beginning, with her unpleasant mother and her horrific school day that starts with Anastasia falling in the mud, didn't make me want to continue reading.
What I really think: I would buy this if I still had readers for Lemony Snicket. Since that series has gone out of favor, I will placate the few readers I do have who want creepy tales of Victorian orphans with Barbara Brooks Wallace and John Bellairs.

Others like it more than I do:
Bluerose's Books
Kirkus Reviews
Middle Grade Mafia
Waking Brain Cells

The Curious World of Calpurnia Tate

Kelly, Jacqueline. The Curious World of Calpurnia Tate.
July 7th 2015 by Henry Holt and Co. (BYR)
ARC from Baker and Taylor

In early 1900s Texas, Callie is increasingly irritated that her brothers get more responsibility, money, and opportunities than she does, based solely on their gender. The biggest case in point is her brother Travis, who loves all animals and repeatedly tries to tame wild ones and bring them home, always with less than satisfactory results. Even though Travis proves to be an ineffective helper to the new veterinarian in town, Dr. Pritzker (Travis tends to get ill at the sight of blood or internal organs), his parents think he could go to college to become a vet-- but Callie may only go for one year, in order to get a teaching license. While Callie's grandfather has worked with her for years to encourage her interest in his scientific pursuits, to the extent that he doesn't even know the names of her brothers, Callie's mother and father seem oddly disconnected from their daughter and have no idea that she is capable enough to not only concoct the anaesthetic for an operation on an animal but to administer it as well. In the wake of the Galveston hurricane, cousin Aggie has come to stay with the family. She is offered an assistant's position at the school and not only demands to be paid, but demands more money than is originally offered! Emboldened by that move, Callie starts saving money for her education herself, even paying Aggie for typewriting lessons and renting her typewriter to use preparing labels and correspondence for Dr. Pritzker. When Aggie surprises the family with her actions, will it decrease Callie's chances of making her own way in the world?
Strengths: This has S.T.E.M. tie-in written all over it! There is weather science, dissecting worms, learning the habits of Texas animals, veterinary science, and all manner of things. Callie is a strong female characer who is shown fearlessly taking advantage of the few opportunities available at the time. Nonfiction about the Galveston storm would be an excellent companion to this.
Weaknesses: The family seemed dysfunctional in odd ways, and Travis didn't seem too bright. If the armadillo stinks and only runs away from you, it probably is not a good pet.
What I really think: I should adore this one. Strong female character, silhouettes on cover, historical fiction... and yet I wasn't thrilled with it. Maybe the Texas setting? Only bought a paperback of the first one. Totally a personal objection-- I can see this being purchased for every middle school library.

Smith, Tamara Ellis. Another Kind of Hurricane
July 14th 2015 by Schwartz & Wade
Copy received from the publisher.

Henry lives in Vermont and is struggling with the death of his best friend and running companion, Wayne. Tavion lives with his father, who paints murals, in New Orleans. He is struggling with death of his mother, and also the loss of the family home during Hurricane Katrina. When Henry's mother gives away a pair of jeans that have a lucky marble that he and Wayne shared, he manages to get a ride with a truck delivering relief supplies to New Orleans in order to try to find it. (Sounds like Kate Brian's Lucky T, doesn't it?) Although Tavion and his father have escaped the hurricane's devastation, Tavion is overcome with guilt over stealing a couple of candy bars from a store and travels back to repay the money. The boys meet up, and with the help of a variety of other somewhat quirky characters, end up back in Vermont together where they can both start to heal.
Strengths: A sad, lyrical story about love and loss set against the background of a riveting historical event. There are a number of Hurricane Katrina books, and this does offer a slight twist to the usual story. I like that the cover displays some diversity.
Weaknesses: This book continues the trend of sad books for middle grade. When people die, the survivors often struggle with these emotions every single day, and Smith portrays these feelings with accuracy and poignancy.
What I really think: People don't want to live these emotions, much less read about them. I wish this were more hopeful.

Darkmouth: The Legends Begin

Hegarty, Shane. Darkmouth: The Legends Begin
April 21st 2015 by HarperCollins
Copy from Young Adult Books Central and reviewed there.

Finn knows that he is going to have to take his father's place fighting the monsters, called Legends, that infect his blighted town of Darkmouth. After all, as his father frequently points out, 42 generations of his ancestors have been keeping the town safe. Darkmouth is the last place with active legends; all of the other towns have managed to closed the portals and are no longer bothered. To make matters worse, Finn is not good at fighting monsters! He trips over his armor, shoots the Desiccator at cars, and generally is unsuccessful in dispatching Legends. When his father is insistent that he be ready in a year so his father can take a place of the board of Legend Hunters and occasionally leave Darkmouth, Finn is not happy. He would rather be a veterinarian. There is some hope when Broonie, a Hogbroon, is sent into the Promised Land with a message for Finn-- in order to defeat the Legends, "the boy must fall". Before Finn can ask what this means, his father desiccates Broonie, which doesn't kill the Legends, but sort of shrink wraps them in suspended animation. Meanwhile, there is intrigue afoot. Trusted auxiliaries become suspect, Finn's father tries to build a suspicious looking device to end the trouble once and for all, and the townspeople are starting to believe that Finn and his father aren't protecting the town-- they are keeping the Legends alive so that they stay employed. When all of these facets converge and the portal opens, Finn's mother and father are sucked through it. Will he be able to find them in time and keep the Legends away from Darkmouth?

Because of his job, and his lack of ability in doing it, Finn has few friends at school. When Emmie moves to town and takes an interest in the Legends, Finn shares a little too much information with her, and discovers that her father is stalking his family! It turns out that he has been sent from the board of Legend Hunters to assess Finn's father, but it is nice to see Finn have someone who can share his interests and help him with his fighting skills. Finn also has some nice interaction with Broonie, and seeing the two of them help each other out even though they are on different sides on the conflict is heartening.

Darkmouth is a quaint, rainy, English village where people don't really want to be, and the descriptions of the town and the people give this book a very brooding atmosphere. There are chapters from A Concise Guide to the Legend Hunter World that give some of the back story without belaboring it.

What makes this a great middle grade fantasy is the description of monsters! A lot of readers are interested in reading about them, but there aren't a lot of books about them other than Lorey's Monster Academy or Gilman's Lovecraft Middle School, or the Scary School or Monsterific Tales series. Those books are a little sillier and for slightly younger readers; Darkmouth is fresh, solidly middle grade and filled with just the right amount of explosions and monster bashing.

MMGM- The Girl in the Torch

Sharenow, Robert. The Girl in the Torch
May 26th 2015 by Balzer + Bray
Copy received from Goldberg McDuffie Communications (Publicity)

When Sarah's father is killed in a pogrom, and her mother becomes very ill on their trip to the US, Sarah finds herself in the custody of immigration. When her mother passes away, she is going to be sent back to her country. Knowing this will not end well, she jumps off the ship and ends up at the Statue of Liberty. There, she has a fairly successful life, sleeping in the statue, scrounging leftover food and saving pennies to take the ferry to the city. When a guard, Maryk, is injured, she helps him. To thank her, he takes her to his boarding house and hands her over to Mrs. Lee, the Chinese landlady, and suggests that Sarah helps out in the kitchen. Sarah is a hard worker, and Mrs. Lee has a soft spot for people in need. Again, things go fairly well. Sarah befriends a Newsie, Tommy, and he turns out to be very helpful when her situation with Mrs. Lee becomes untenable. Luckily, Sarah's command of English and her willingness to stand up to authority figures saves the day.
Strengths: This is different from the usual immigrant story, where the child ends up in a sweatshop, and has a lot more action. The characters are all appealing, even Maryk, who is tragically flawed but helps Sarah when she really needs it. The different sections of New York City are well described, and the kindness of the strangers who help Sarah is a wonderful thing to have in a book. Reminded me a bit of Napoli's The King of Mulberry Street.
Weaknesses: While I can understand why Sharenow would want to be vague about country of origin so the tale is more universal (which is often not successful, see Close to the Wind), I'm a fan of specifics in historical fiction. More details about daily life (food, clothing, atmosphere) would have been something I would have enjoyed.
What I really think: Historical fiction is a hard sell, but this has enough appealing elements that I think it will circulate well, so I will buy a copy. Wish the cover were a little better.

You Me Him

Dinnison, Kris. You Me Him
July 7th 2015 by HMH Books for Young Readers
ARC from Baker and Taylor

Maggie and Nash are the best of friends, and glad to have each other. Nash's mother is an alcoholic and frequently takes all of his attention, while Maggie's mother is well meaning but really pushy about Maggie's weight. When a new and charistmatic boy, Tom, comes to town and wants to hang with their misfit group (which includes Cece, Maggie's other best friend), Nash calls dibs on him as a romantic prospect. Maggie is okay with that, and fills her time with working at a used record store and baking cookies to give away. As time goes on, however, Maggie begins to realize that Tom is not attracted to Nash, but may very well be attracted to her. She feels bad that her friend will once again be thwarted in his crush, but is also pleased that Tom likes her. Adding to the drama is Kayla, who also likes Tom, but is one of the popular girls. She also used to be good friends with Maggie before she annihilated her reputation in middle school. Kayla claims to want to be friends again because the popular people are "boring", but Maggie is still wary. When things go wrong with Nash over Tom, all the cookies in the world won't make Maggie feel better.
Strengths: Very good job at portrayed a high school same sex crush, and Tom is very understanding and not judgemental or weirded out by Nash. There's also not a whole lot of drinking or talk of sex, which is highly unusual in a book with LGBTQ characters for some reason. I really liked the journey that the main characters were on, especially the descriptions of Maggie and her mother's tension over weight. A must purchase for high school and public libraries. My choice for Stonewall winner this year.
Weaknesses: Still a bit much for high school, with several f-bombs and a general slow, introspective tone. I will give my ARC to one of my 8th grade girls who is the only student in 13 years to ask for books with LGBTQ characters. I know, I know-- students don't ASK for this kind of books, but more often than not I recommend books to students based on other qualities of the characters, only to have them bring back One Man Guy having only read three chapters. Argh. Hard to balance.
What I really think: Still on the look out for middle grade gender role diversity.

Song of Summer

First.... ARGH!!! E Book only. This is soooo irritating. Yes, Netgalley mentioned way down at the bottom that Spark books are only available as e books (like Any Way You Slice It), but the cover and book description made this so appealing that I didn't look at that part. I can't do anything with e only books. Grrrrrr. I really, really want both of these titles IN HARDCOVER!!!

Anderson, Laura Lee. Song of Summer
July 7th 2015 by Bloomsbury Spark
E ARC from Netgalley.com

Robin works as a waitress in a small diner near the ritzy community of Chautauqua. She is saving her tip money for a new guitar, since she plays in a band (with ex-boyfriend Trent) and loves music. The older waitresses joke with her about finding the "perfect man" and her list of qualifications is on the staff bulletin board. When dishy Carter comes in with his friend, she thinks at first that the two are on a date, but it turns out that Carter isn't speaking because he is deaf. There is an instant attraction between the two, and Carter later rides his motorcycle back, the two exchange information, and eventually go on a date. They go to an arts festival, have picnics, and eat dinner at each other's homes. Robin learns some sign language but is somewhat intimidated when she meets Carter's family and friends. Carter appreciates that his deafness doesn't faze Robin. There is a misunderstanding near the end of the book, and the two waste the last couple of weeks of summer not speaking, reconnecting briefly at the end to reconcile, but also realize that their romance, while intense. doesn't have much of a future.
Strengths: A fabulous summer romance with gentle kisses in scenic locations, PLUS there is a lot of diversity that is there but not dwelt upon. Carter is vaguely multiracial, and his family has three adopted children, all with various stages of hearing impairment. Love the cover, love the ending, want to be able to hand this to my students in the fall.
Weaknesses: E Book only. ARRRRGGG!!!
What I really think: This is exactly what I need for my 8th grade girls-- high school type romances without sex or foul language. These are rather hard to find, which makes me even more frustrated that these aren't published as a paperback, at least.

Old School Saturday--Octagon Magic

Norton, Andre. Octagon Magic
December 1st 2005 by Starscape
Originally published 1967 by Hamish Hamilton

Came across this in the bunch of books from Half Price books that were donated for my students' summer reading.

Lorrie comes to the US from Canada to live with her aunt when her grandmother becomes ill. Her aunt is a busy career woman, so leaves her to her own devices or, worse, to the care of a neighbor with rambunctious children. She is given a hard time by some of the boys in her class (They taunt her with "Canuck, walks like a duck!" I can only imagine how much trouble they would be in at my school if they did that!), and while running from some of them, happens across an octagonal house where a "witch" lives. When she returns to the property to bury her antique doll that the neighbor girl has broken, she meets Hallie, the maid of the "witch", who turns out to be the very nice Miss Ashemeade. Miss Ashmeade asks Lorrie's aunt (by letter!) if Lorrie can visit her, and the two begin sessions of needlework, appreciation for antiques, and some magic visits via a dollhouse and a rocking horse. Miss Ashemeade's wonderful house is in danger of being torn down to make room for a freeway, and she and Hattie manage to "go away", leaving Lorrie several of the nicer (and more magical) antiques.
Strengths: I adore books with elderly neighbors, dolls, wonderful old houses, antiques, AND we get some bonus needlework thrown in. I am sure that Charlotte's Library would adore this, even though Dragon Magic wasn't quite as good. I'm surprised that I didn't read this when I was in middle school. Or maybe I did. It felt a bit like Tom's Midnight Garden.
Weaknesses: Wow. Were the 1960s really a time when people let their children randomly hang with neighbors they didn't know. Of course, The Lost Track of Time had that as well. The plot of this didn't hang together too well, and the magic came out of nowhere.
What I really think: The Ruth Chew books have been tremendously popular in my library, mainly because I love them SO much. If these were available in hard cover editions, I might be tempted. But probably not, since I can't even get students to read Barrows' Magic in the Mix series, which is newer.

Saving Mr. Terupt

Buyea, Rob. Saving Mr. Terupt.
July 14th 2015 by Delacorte Books for Young Readers
E ARC from Netgalley.com

Starting middle school is hard for Mr. Terupt's former students, for a variety of reasons. Danielle is mortified by some of her classmates, and is not feeling well for most of the year. Lexie manages to tone down her maturity, but has to deal with the illness of her mother. Anna keeps waiting for Charlie to propose to her mother. Jessica keeps her journal, and goes to a writing camp where she meets someone unexpected. Peter and Jeffrey are excited to be on the wrestling team, working with Mr. Bobur, their science teacher. Luke is having the hardest time-- he is taking advanced classes and so is not with his friends, and is getting picked on because of his small size and geekiness. There is a class election that pits Lexie against Peter, with the vote being taken in December. In addition to the various illnesses, Mrs. Terupt is pregnant and not doing well. The biggest issue, however, is the school budget. Even though the necessary cuts are explained to the local people, they don't care if Mr. Terupt, as the newest hire, loses his job. The students try very hard to save his job, but the levy fails. Not to worry, though-- help comes from an unexpected source.
Strengths: Finally, Mr. Buyea puts a good deal of wrestling details in a book, and the drama of middle school (from lockers to lunches) is nicely covered. A party that goes "wild" with kissing in a closet is an expecially nice touch. Fans of Because of Mr. Terupt and Mr. Terupt Falls Again will be happy.
Weaknesses: While the wrestling is great, it can't be followed up with an episode detailing bra shopping! I'm never a fan of elections, and as far as school budgets go-- if you're the last hired, you're the last out, and it doesn't matter how good you are. I wish someone had explained that to the students. Their efforts are completely useless.
What I really think: While the first book goes out maybe once or twice a year, I didn't even buy the second book. These books always strike me as a teacher fantasy. We would all like to be remembered, but it's closer to the truth to think that students pretty much forget us the minute they walk out of the building in May.

The Fixer (The Fixer #1)

Barnes, Jennifer Lynn. The Fixer (The Fixer #1)
July 7th 2015 by Bloomsbury Children's
E ARC from Netgalley.com

When Tess's grandfather's memory becomes progressively worse, her older sister, Ivy, steps in and whisks her away to Washington, while her grandfather is given excellent medical care in Boston. Tess is enrolled in Hardwicke, a private school where all of her classmates seem to have some connection to the upper echelon of Washington, D.C.'s ruling class. When Tess takes care of a bully for the vice president's daughter, she establishes the same reputation her sister has-- she fixes problems. Ivy's work is very secretive, but soon becomes enmeshed with the complications at Hardwicke. Henry's grandfather has died... Supreme Court Justice Marquette. Vivvie thinks her father might have had something to do with it... her father, Major Bharani, is the White House physician. Add into the mix "kingmaker" William Keyes, who seems to be behind the nomination for Judge Pierce to replace Marquette, and things get very complicated very fast. Tess, Vivvie and Henry, along with several other friends, try to figure out what's going on without telling Ivy too much. They make some progress, but the body count keeps climbing, and eventually Tess's life is imperiled as well. Between the government secrets and family ones, Ivy and Tess have a lot of ground to cover before they can connect as a family.

For fans of Ally Carter's Gallagher Girls series or Anabel Mongahan's A Girl Called Digit, this is a politically charged, convoluted mystery with a great private school connection. Even though Tess is new to the Washington scene, and her roots on a Montana ranch are never downplayed, she quickly becomes knowledgeable about the in and outs of political intrigue. While her initial investigations are spurred because of her concern for classmates, she quickly realizes that much more is at stake. This is all done in a convincing manner, which is important because... well, couldn't any of us arrive in Washington and soon work our way into the inner circle, uncovering all of its secrets? The Fixer allows the reader to plunge right into the story and be a part of the political machinations!

Even though there are a number of characters, Barnes does a good job at giving them all distinct personalities. While there isn't a romance in this book, there is a chance in the second book (coming out in 2016) to choose between the proper, respectful Henry and the goofy, irresponsible Asher. Ivy has just enough mystery about what she does to make her interesting, and I'm now really curious to see what her "driver", Bodie, has in his background. There are a number of characters killed off, but the murders occur off screen, making this a young adult book that is also suitable for middle grade readers, unlike The Naturals series, which was graphically violent.

Barnes is a facile writer, and The Fixer is a riveting page turner. There are several twists I should have seen coming and didn't, and I can't wait to get back to D.C. and find out what Tess's next adventure will be!

#WeNeedDiverseBooks Wednesday-- Adventures with Waffles

Parr, Maria. Adventures with Waffles
May 12th 2015 by Candlewick Press
First published in 2005, in Norwegian

Lena and Trille live in a small coastal town near the mountains in Norway. Lena has a single mother, whom she would like to fix up with the local doctor, who pays many visits to Lena's house, since she is always involved in some adventure that leads to an accident. Trille has supportive parents, a sister adopted for Colombia, his grandfather, and Auntie Granny, his grandfather's sister, who makes the eponymous waffles. Smoking haddocks, do the children get into adventures. They take the ferry to the mainland and busk in order to earn money to buy a soccer ball, pretend to be living during WWII, unfortunately involving the resident of a nursing home who thinks that WWII is still going on, and facilitating Lena's running away when her mother wants to move away from Trille's family. Told in anecdotes that take us through a year, this book showcases everyday Norwegian life.
Strengths: This had the feel of classic children's literature, so fans of The Penderwicks, Elizabeth Enright, or my favorite picture books, Flicka, Ricka and Dicka will like this. I learned a few things about life in Norway, including the fact that people still wear wooden shoes on farms. Love the cover.
Weaknesses: A bit too young for middle school.
What I really think: An optional purchase for most schools, although fun if there is a large Norwegian population.

Lena's birthday is tomorrow, and so is mine!

Battle Bugs/ Serafina and the Black Cloak

Patton, Jack. The Lizard Wars (Battle Bugs #1)
May 26th 2015 by Scholastic Paperbacks
ARC from Young Adult Books Central and reviewed there.

Max loves insects of all kinds, and his bedroom is festooned with a spider clock, rubber bugs, and a couple of real walking stick insects. When his mother gets him an old copy of The Complete Encyclopedia of Arthropods, which even comes with a magnifying glass in a pocket, he's thrilled. Delving into the book, he notices a map with Lizard Island and Bug Island. When he looks more closely with the magnifying glass, he gets a tingly feeling and finds himself on Bug Island. He meets Spike, a scorpion who is going to take him back to Barton, the leader of the bugs, and Max is worried that Spike will eat him or sting him. When he helps Spike defend himself from a lizard, using his knowledge of the lizard's weakest point, Spike is impressed. Barton is, too, especially since a volcano has created a bridge between the two islands, and General Komodo and his lizard army are attacking the bugs. Max assesses the situation, and using his knowledge of the capabilities of each bug, comes up with a plan to evacuate when it's clear that the bugs can't defeat the lizards.

The world building in The Lizard War is great-- even though Max sees bugs from all over his world, they are all in one place because they are part of an army. The artifice of using the magnifying glass to travel to a different world is a good one, since it is simple, effective, and works both ways. It's especially charming that the bugs help Max figure out how to get home.

The best part of the story is how seamlessly the facts about bugs are woven into the action and described just enough. Readers who are enthralled with bugs will want to read this with a reference book by their side so they can look at pictures of the real bugs and find out if bombardier beetles really DO shoot acid out of their bottoms!

Beginning readers who like a lot of action combined with science facts will find themselves wishing for their own magical magnifying glass so that they, like Max, can ride on a scorpion and fist bump an emperor beetle.

Patton, Jack. The Spider Siege (Battle Bugs #2)
May 26th 2015 by Scholastic Paperbacks
ARC from Young Adult Books Central and reviewed there.

After seeing a spider with an impressive web on a family camping trip, Max once again travels magically to Bug Island, where the lizards are once again encroaching on the bugs. General Komodo has found a pass through the mountains, and Barton needs help planning battle strategy. Things look grim, but Max realizes that the Golden Orb Weaver spiders can use their webs to block off the pass and by the bugs some time. He also has the shy Trap Door Spider, Webster, dig burrows under the bug encampment just in case. While the lizards are held off for a bit, they eventually break through, but are ambushed brilliantly by the bombardier beetles and are sent on their way. Termites are then used to close off the path, but what will happen when the lizards find another way to attack the bugs?

While this is a good adventure series for younger readers, this volume did have a couple of disturbing acts of bug violence-- a scorpion stinger is driven into a lizard's open mouth, fire ants sting the lizards and leave them moaning in pain, and Barton grabs General Komodo's tongue with his pincers! Readers who are sensitive to this sort of graphic violence, even if it is concerning bugs, might want to pass.

The battle strategy involving the bugs is really brilliant. While the spiders are using extra strength webbing, the lizards are using the spiky headed variety of their kind to rip through it. For me, the lizards almost win this battle with their ingenuity-- they have tree snakes and chameleons serving as spies, and ably counter every defense that Max comes up with.

The inclusion of Webster, the shy Trap Door Spider, was interesting, and Spike and Barton are certainly distinct personalities.

This series definitely lends itself to some imaginative play, and I can see young bug enthusiasts planning their battle strategies with an entomological guide by their side. If they have a magnifying glass, they'll have to be careful with it or the lizards will be the least of their "army's" worries!


Beatty, Robert. Serafina and the Black Cloak.
July 14th 2015 by Disney-Hyperion
E ARC from Netgalley

Serafina's father works with the machines on the sprawling Biltmore estate. The two have always lived in a corner of the basement, and while Serafina wanders out at night to kill rats and occasionally pick up a book to read, she is never to be seen my anyone on the estate. She doesn't even have proper clothing-- she wears an old shirt of her father's lest anyone ask questions should her father buy clothes in town for her. When Serafina sees a man in a black cloak make a girl in a yellow dress disappear in the middle of the night, she is scared, and when it turns out that other children are missing as well, she knows that she needs to do something. Luckily, she makes the acquaintance of Braeden Vanderbilt and his dog, and he listens to her improbable story and tries to help her. The two have a few leads, and pursue them even though they are putting themselves in danger. There is a great evil at work, and when they find the man they think is responsible, even bigger mysterires are revealed. Can Braeden and Serafina put an end to the disappearances, and will Serafina's secret existence get her and the young Vanderbilt into even more trouble?
Strengths: This had some very gory scenes as well as some scary ones. Early on, there are some fairly graphic descriptions of Serafina killing rats, and the man in the black cloak likes to frequent an old and very creepy graveyard. The Biltmore estate setting is an interesting historical one as well. Braeden is a lovely character who was very fully developed, and I liked his interactions with Serafina.
Weaknesses: There was a LOT going on in this book, but I don't want to spoil the various twists. This contributed to the books lack of focus. Going from horror scenes to more pleasant, historically oriented ones was a bit jarring, especially since students who read horror usually don't like historical descriptions and vice versa.
What I really think: Well-written and intriguing, but may struggle to find an audience.