Monday, September 23, 2013

MMGM--Sky Jumpers

Sky Jumpers (Sky Jumpers, #1)Eddleman, Peggy. Sky Jumpers
24 September 2013, Random House Books for Young Readers
ARC from Baker and Taylor

Far enough in the future that I will be dead, Hope is living in a world partially destroyed by World War III and "green bombs". Scientists thought that they could avert some damage of the bombs in previous wars, but they succeeded only in creating a world that could be lived in... if people survive. Hope's community of white rock is surrounded by the "bomb's breath"; air that is chemically changed so that it kills people. It also has knocked out the abilities of magnets, so it's hard to use electricity in the way it is used now. Since so much technology disappeared, the town puts a heavy emphasis on people inventing things, and Hope always fails miserably at the yearly contests, which she feels disappoints her adoptive parents, especially since she is always taking reckless chances, like jumping through the bomb's breath area for fun. When the town is attacked by bandits who want White Rocks antibiotics and injure Hope's father, she knows that she has to use her daredevil skills to save him. She and her friend Aaren set off to a neighboring town to get the guards but have to contend with a blizzard as well as Aaren's young sister Brenna, who runs away to join them. It's hard going, but Hope perseveres and ends up realizing that even though she can't invent things, she can contribute to her community.
Strengths: The world building of this is interesting and within the realm of possibility. I liked that Hope, though orphaned, had a support network. Lots of good action and survival scenes. I didn't think that I would like this one when I picked it up since it had a generic fantasy cover and dystopia has been done to death, but I found myself enjoying this more than I thought. I liked Hope, too, which helped.
Weaknesses: Book two is scheduled for next September, but I wish this were a stand alone since there are SO few of them in middle grade literature! I thought the story was complete, although I'm not averse to reading more about Hope.

It's Marvelous Middle Grade Monday at Ramblings of a Wannabe Scribe and What Are You Reading? day at Teach Mentor Texts and Unleashing Readers. It's also Nonfiction Monday, with the Round Up this week at Sally's Bookshelf.

If you deal with mainly middle grade literature, you should hop over to Charlotte's Library and read her post on "Middle Grade Bloggers as Fans, Gatekeepers, Partners of the Industry, & Members of a Gender-Imbalanced Community, Part I ". This very nearly lead to a Blather post from me, but I'm still thinking about it. I just read a realistic fiction book by an author who is very active in the Kidlitosphere and seems like a nice person, but I can't see any of my students being interested in the book. At all. This has happened before, and I'm never sure what to do. In my reviews, I try to be very clear that I am considering MY students and what THEY will read, but honestly, this often means "What on earth was this author thinking?" The book was perfectly fine, very well written, and the occasional student might find it interesting,  but I need
books that are immediately interesting to students, so I won't be buying this.

If you can't see students being interested in books you read, do you review them? Or just quietly skip mentioning them on your blog?


  1. Sky Jumpers sounds like fun. Think I'll add it to my to be read pile. Thanks for the reviews.

  2. Hi there Miss Yingling, i have a special affinity towards David Macaulay, but it's the first I've heard of this title. Hopefully we also have it in our library.
    Regarding your question, I don't review books I don't really enjoy or would NOT recommend to anyone at all. Seems like a waste of space and time to even include it in our blog.

  3. Since I work at an elementary school, I don't have students looking at my blog. I read widely and try to review everything lately. Love the two books you talked about today and will have to check them out!

    The Monster Report

  4. Glad you enjoyed Sky Jumpers. I did too. I don't think there are many dystopian or post-apocalyptic books for MG so I found that refreshing. And Hope's such a great character.

  5. I shall look forward to Sky Jumper more enthusiastically now! Thanks.

  6. My kids loved "The Way Things Work" - does this one have the excellent drawings? I think Macaulay inspired one of my kids to take architecture and CAD classes in high school.

  7. David Macaulay's books are always fun. Thanks for the heads up.

  8. Thanks for the additional Macauley title. It'll be a great addition to the Doucette's collection.
    I thought your question about reviewing resources you dislike interesting. I don't necessarily blog about them unless I see that it illustrates a way to think about resources. My audience is not children but adults and many of them are student teachers learning about children's literature. So sometimes a less than stellar book can be useful to highlight some feature that might be problematic. Otherwise I do tend to focus on the books that I think would make great classroom resources. That being said, I do find reviews that are critical helpful when I'm selecting resources to add to the Doucette Library's collection. Good question.
    Apples with Many Seeds

  9. I think that since your focus is on books that you're evaluating for your students, it makes sense for you to not review books that don't work for you. For me, I don't have as clear an audience, so I'd be more likely to go ahead. But I think that the presence or absence of kid-appeal is a valid thing to bring up, for sure.

  10. I definitely have to get Sky Jumpers. It sounds perfect for my middle school kids.

  11. I haven't heard of Sky Jumpers or the Toilet book by MacCauley so thank you for sharing those. I guess you're right about not sharing a book if you are writing just for your students. If I read a book I really don't like at all, I think I would not review it, but if it has value, I think others should know about it so they can determine if there's some student who might enjoy reading it. If you are looking for middle grade apocalyptic books, the series of Life As We Knew It by Susan Beth Pfeffer is very good. I don't know how young a middle grade student you mean. This first book is well done, the one in New York is a little more graphic, and the last one is good, offering hope. Sorry if I'm repeating what you've known a while.