data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0403c/0403c0bd256400f98b64be1e98979d8921f02e33" alt=""
Deo and his brother Innocent do their best to enjoy life in their Zimbabwean village even though war rages around them and they are constantly hungry. When the soldiers come and demand food from an American shipment that has not arrived, Innocent, who is mentally challenged, gets upset and runs off. When the brothers return to the village, their family and many of their neighbors have been killed. They take off to seek the help of their mother's friend, but are told that they will need to go to South Africa in order to be safe. After a harrowing trip across a wild animal preserve, they make it to South Africa, where they are glad to get low paying jobs on a tomato farm. When the locals start harassing them for being foreign, they go to the big city and find a community under a bridge, where they set up residence, and Deo is able to play soccer again. There is still a lot of prejudice and hatred against foreigners, and Deo is not able to keep Innocent safe.
Strengths: Like Perkins' Bamboo People, this is a harrowing account of a place in the world with which many students will not be familiar. While we have not had any students from Zimbabwe, we have many from Ghana and Somalia, and this might help students understand why so many family flee their own countries and come to the United States. Boys will like this because of the difficulties faced by Deo. There's definitely an adrenaline rush in both the descriptions of fighting and soccer.
Weaknesses: This might be too violent for 5th and 6th graders, but is certainly something that older students should read.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c4c5e/c4c5ee6a9943c28947d0b5f67f847f1fab2dc6ab" alt=""
Sequel to Portia's Ultra Mysterious Double Life
Portia lives with her mother who runs an organic vegetarian restaurant and frequently makes Portia eat her odd experiments. A new girl who is very fond of animals of all kinds, Misty, who enlists Portia's help with all manner of bug and critter related tasks and mysteries. A budding detective, Portia is also trying to find her father, not alienate her best friend, Amy, and keep up with her school work.
Strengths: The girls love the Aladdin Mix books and will often read one a night. Anything dealing with friendship is an easy sell in middle school.
Weaknesses: This was published in 2009 and already is technologically dated, since Portia relies heavily on her PDA. Now she would just have an iPhone. On a personal pet peeve level, I didn't like the goofy names, like Portia Avatar or Mr. Scuzzy, the teacher.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ec412/ec412c69637e9563545d147f0a8baafd1194bd47" alt=""
Amen! And what my boys really want are funny books about school situations, action books, and a little romance. Yes, romance, just from a boy perspective.
And skateboarding. I actually e mailed Mr. Lipsyte and asked that he write a skateboarding book. He said if he did, he would name a character after me. I'm still waiting!!
Bravo to you, Ms. Yingling, for contacting Mr. Lipsyte.
ReplyDeleteAnd thanks for the nice mention.
I am so glad you brought this to people's attention. You seemed the perfect person to do so.
Have you read Stupid Fast by Geoff Herbach? It's one of my favorite realistic YA novels of the year and features a male protagonist.
ReplyDeleteIf you get a moment check out Carl Deuker's website, especially the ask question section. Its just shows how much Deuker's fans love him
I have much respect for Lipsyte, Raiders Night is one of the best YA football novels but Deuker is the best YA sports authors out.
Two more great books for boys that have nothing to do with sports.
How I Nicky Flynn Finally Get A Life And A Dog
And, The Secret World of Ms. Finkleman
Thanks for the recommendations, Doret. I did read Stupid Fast (http://msyinglingreads.blogspot.com/2011/06/stupid-fast.html)as well as Nicky Flynn (http://msyinglingreads.blogspot.com/2010/12/guy-and-his-dog.html)and adore Deuker. I have multiple copies of all his books and none of them are in. I've just requested Ms. Finkleman, which looks good!
ReplyDelete