Friday, November 20, 2026

Guy Friday- All Mixed Up

Tawney, Raj. All Mixed Up 
November 17, 2026 by Paw Prints Publishing
Copy provided by the Publisher

Kamal Rao is a 6th grader on Long Island in 2002. He is multi-ethnic, with an Indian father and Puerto Rican/Italian mother. The other children in his school are not kind, calling him "Brillo head" and giving him "purple nurples", among other injustices. When he is saved from the latest onslaught from bully Tyler by Jaz Rafiq, he is intrigued by this new student enough that they become friends. Jaz is vague about why he has moved to the area, saying only that he lives in the Mayfair apartments and that his dad is out of work. Kamal's father is also looking for a new job, which is causing some tension in their extended family, including Kamal's mother's mother in the Bronx. When Kamal's family is invited to an engagement party, he asked Jaz to come along. The other boys their age are "Bruppies" (brown yuppies) and give them a hard time; Kamal retaliates by putting earthworms in the boys' food, inspiring the cover. It turns out that Jaz is living with his uncle, who is in the country without documentation, while his parents remain in Pakistan. When there is an attack on the New York City parade, everyone is afraid, and Muslims are targeted with hate crimes. Jaz disappears, and Kamal can find no information about where he has gone. In the end, there is some indication that Jaz has moved to Dearborn, Michigan, which has a large Muslim population. 
Strengths: Kamal loves his family and doesn't think much about been multi-ethnic, except when people at school give him a hard time. Seeing the experiences of someone new to the US gives him a bit of perspective, and he sees Jaz's resilience in the face of bigger obstacles. This is a short book (155 pages) and has a good balance of scenes at school and at home. Jaz is a bit of a mystery, and his fate is one suffered by many immigrant children, but which doesn't get a lot of coverage in books. It would be interesting to read about Jaz's life in Dearborn, which is where Fahmy's Huda F lives. 
Weaknesses: I wish this had done more to address the anti-immigrant state of the US in the wake of 9/11, like Cerra's Just a Drop of Water did. It did touch on it a little, but it would have been good to have a little more discussion for tween readers who don't have a good grasp on this history. The cover may not appeal to all readers. 
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who want to get a different perspective on the immigrant or first generation experience and have enjoyed titles like Week and Varadarajan's Save Me a Seat  or Kelkar's American as Paneer Pie. 

No comments:

Post a Comment