October 13, 2026 by Quill Tree Books
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus
It's always been just eleven-year-old Addie and her mother, but when a car accident ends with her mother being in a coma in the ICU, Addie's custody goes to her half brother Julian, whom she has not seen since she was four. She's spent some time with her best friend Thea's family, but being alone in her townhouse with Julian is awkward. She's very worried about her mother, but trying to put a brave face on it. She wants to rely on the help of Thea and her other best friend, Luz, but after a typical middle school scuffle, the two don't want to be friends any more. Julian is 24, has graduated from Boston College after being raised in nearby Stamford by his father, and is able to work from home. Since the two are such strangers, they don't talk much, which leads to some logistical problems like bathroom use, being late to school, and scheduling in swim practices. Addie does make the attempt to give Julian swim lessons so the two can bond, but her brother refuses to discuss why he has cut off their mother. After sneaking into her mother's closet and going through some of her boxes, Addie does find some alarming new that she doesn't quite understand. She reaches out to her own social worker, Stacey, her school counselor, and her friends, but no one can really help her. Luckily, her mother improves, and things are going okay with Julian, but Addie doesn't get the answers that she needs. How long will it take for her to understand her complicated family?
Strengths: It is much more realistic to portray, as Marks puts it in an introductory note, "non-traditional and complicated family dynamics". Addie's father isn't in the picture, but she's had a good explanation for his absence and is okay with it. Friend drama is a huge part of middle school, and it is tough when your two best friends no longer speak to you. Julian is well portrayed as a young man willing to step up for his sister in a way that his mother was not able to step up for him because of her struggles with depression. Including swimming in this mix is great, because tweens don't stop being tweens because they have family problems. The brief appearance by Ms. Martin, the school counselor, is quite nice, and the teachers know about Addie's mother's accident but don't belabor the point.
Strengths: It is much more realistic to portray, as Marks puts it in an introductory note, "non-traditional and complicated family dynamics". Addie's father isn't in the picture, but she's had a good explanation for his absence and is okay with it. Friend drama is a huge part of middle school, and it is tough when your two best friends no longer speak to you. Julian is well portrayed as a young man willing to step up for his sister in a way that his mother was not able to step up for him because of her struggles with depression. Including swimming in this mix is great, because tweens don't stop being tweens because they have family problems. The brief appearance by Ms. Martin, the school counselor, is quite nice, and the teachers know about Addie's mother's accident but don't belabor the point.
Strengths: Every family has divisions, and some are more significant than others. It makes perfect sense that Addie's mother wanted to keep information about Julian private, and it also tracks that the two of them got along well before the mother's accident. This does have an important message for adults about making plans for children; I think my best friend was VERY relieved when my children all were over 18 and she no longer had to worry about anything happening to me that would result in her being their guardian! The scenes alternated nicely between home, school, and extracurricular activities; I was starting to wonder if tweens had sleepovers anymore, since they are not portrayed in books very much. It was interesting that Addie didn't have a cell phone, but the book could easily be used by a tween a proof as to why they should have one! Julian was a bit shadowy as a character, but it was endearing how he stepped up and really did his best to take care of Addie. The ending is happy, and the world definitely needs more happy endings!
Weaknesses: I wish there had been more about Addie and Julian's developing relationship rather than the incident with the mother's accident. As a middle grade student, the thought of one's mother unconscious in an ICU would have superceded any concern in my own mind. The way Addie pried into her mother's things was concerning as well, although I did appreciate that she apologized to her friends and Julian for not respecting their space and decisions.
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who like books about nontraditional or struggling families, like Moss' Birdy, Draper's Blended or Respicio's Isabel in Bloom.
Weaknesses: I wish there had been more about Addie and Julian's developing relationship rather than the incident with the mother's accident. As a middle grade student, the thought of one's mother unconscious in an ICU would have superceded any concern in my own mind. The way Addie pried into her mother's things was concerning as well, although I did appreciate that she apologized to her friends and Julian for not respecting their space and decisions.
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who like books about nontraditional or struggling families, like Moss' Birdy, Draper's Blended or Respicio's Isabel in Bloom.

























No comments:
Post a Comment