March 25, 2025 by Greenwillow Books
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus
Natalie Lee (aka Nat or Cincinnati) lives with her mother, who does fundraising for an art museum, and attends the Manhattan Academy of Arts and Sciences, a private school. She is trying to break the family curse, and thinks if she can steal the Chachapoyas Idol, a Peruvian artifact that her grandfather, Pops, removed from the country, from the museum and give it to the Belaundes, the curse might be lifted. Even though she is successful in removing the idol, someone steals it from her! Pops had been a victim of the curse when he had a public freak out at a museum gala. He's now living ina nursing facility Cincinnati, and since his great great granddaughter wants to follow in the family footsteps and be an archaeologist as well, she's interested in all of his work. At school, she has to deal with Sebastian Thomas, who is also descended from archaeologists, but isn't very nice. After finding out he stole the idol, and scuffling about it at school, she is suspended for a week. Her friend Felix, who works in the art department at the museum, picks her up from school, and is working on another replacement forgery for the idol. Armed with her new friend Parsley's invitation to the auction where Sebastian's family is trying to sell the idol, Cincinnati manages to switch out the idol again, so that she can get the original to the Balaundes, but when she goes to give it to them, it has cracked. This disappointment leads her to get roped into finding a Spear that has Biblical ties, that Craft Raft founder's daughter Taylor Calloway is trying to locate. She and Parsely join forces again. There's kidnapping, ancient maps, gun shots, a trip to Europe, and a lot of adventure as Cincinnati
Strengths: This is on trend with current thoughts about antiquities trafficking and colonization, and Cincinnati is very concerned about getting relics returned to their countries of origin. Young readers will enjoy the fact that Cincinnati pushes the envelope and doesn't always listen to her mother or think about her own safety; the dedication mentions favoring justice over self-preservation. Cincinnati has some help from the quirky Parsely (whose father manufactures komboucha and whose mother is a famous singer), and seems to have plenty of resources to help her deal with artifacts. Her Pops has drunk from the fountain of youth, and is in a nursing facility under sedation, so I'm curious to see if this becomes a series so that we can get more information about him.
Weaknesses: There are a lot of art and pop cultural mentions that I don't think my students will understand. Also, it would have been good to know more about the curse that Cincinnati was working so hard to break.
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who enjoyed Blue Balliet's art mysteries, LaFevers' Theodosia Throckmorton series or who want a fictional take on something like Albee's Accidental Archaeologists.
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who enjoyed Blue Balliet's art mysteries, LaFevers' Theodosia Throckmorton series or who want a fictional take on something like Albee's Accidental Archaeologists.