March 4, 2025 by Graphix
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus
Mia has problems with social anxiety that have led to years of increasing selective mutism, but she makes a goal for herself to talk in class as she enters middle school. Her first day is a bust, but other students, including former best friend and current nemesis, Chloe, tell the teachers that Mia just doesn't talk. This isn't evident at home, where Mia talks to her mother and father, as well as her younger sister Madeleine, who occasionally helps her with her computer animation projects. Under the name Danger Cat Studios, Mia uploads videos like Tommy Tomato and Bobby Banana. When she puts up posters at school advertising these, she gets a lot of views, and finds it amusing that no one knows she is responsible. She creates puppets to use in the videos, and makes one of Alex, a cool nonbinary kid on whom she has a bit of a crush. They stick up for Mia when classmates make fun of her, and even partners with her on a school project. Alex is surprised that Mia speaks at home, and the two have more fun with the animation projects than the school one. It doesn't go well, since Mia is dealing with the fact that Chloe is living with her family while her parents are taking care of her grandmother. Mia remembers that Chloe, in second grade, told her to quit pestering her, and has trouble when Chloe invites friends to the house. At one point, she suspects that Chloe has poisoned her spaghetti, and spirals to the point where her parents call the paramedics. Mia's grades aren't good, and when Mia's teacher finally calls her mother, the parents find out that Mia hasn't been talking at school. They get her in to therapy, and she slowly progresses from whispering to Alex, which isn't so hard, to speaking in front of groups.
Strengths: One of my second grade classmates was selectively mute, and this was very hard to understand as a child, so it's interesting to see this representation, especially since the author had a lesser degree of this condition when he was young. Mia and Chloe's friend drama makes sense (I personally still have grudges from elementary school!), but I was glad to see that Chloe wasn't really still mean to Mia, and her feelings were a little bit hurt as well. Alex sticking up for Mia and befriending her was also good to see. Mia's animation hobby was intriguing, and it wasn't unusual that her grades slipped in middle school. Steinke's illustrations (Mr. Wolf's Class) will appeal to middle school readers.
Weaknesses: I found it hard to believe that the parents didn't know that Mia wasn't speaking in class. When Mia didn't speak in middle school, the first thing that a teacher would do would be to check her file for diagnosis and accomodations, and when nothing was there, a phone call home would have been made!
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who like all of the graphic novels that deal with challenging middle school experiences. Raina Telgemeier set the bar with Smile, and these have continued with Hale's Real Friends, Durfy-Lavoie's Just Roll With It, Libenson's Invisible Emmy, Page's Button Pusher, Palmer's Campy Prodigy, Scrivan's Nat Enough, and many other titles.
Weaknesses: I found it hard to believe that the parents didn't know that Mia wasn't speaking in class. When Mia didn't speak in middle school, the first thing that a teacher would do would be to check her file for diagnosis and accomodations, and when nothing was there, a phone call home would have been made!
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who like all of the graphic novels that deal with challenging middle school experiences. Raina Telgemeier set the bar with Smile, and these have continued with Hale's Real Friends, Durfy-Lavoie's Just Roll With It, Libenson's Invisible Emmy, Page's Button Pusher, Palmer's Campy Prodigy, Scrivan's Nat Enough, and many other titles.
No comments:
Post a Comment