Tuesday, December 07, 2010

Payback Time

Deuker, Carl. Payback Time.
Dan "Mitch" (as in Michelin Man) True is getting by. Life is full of little disappointments-- he isn't made newspaper editor, he's overweight, and girls aren't interested in him. But it's okay, because he has plans. He throws himself into his assignment as a sports reporter for the school paper, especially when it means spending a lot of time with Kimi, who does photography and is determined to get into an Ivy League college. When the two uncover a possible big story about a new football player, they hope that breaking the story will help them with their college plans. But what will the effect be on the new player? This story will keep readers guessing until the end.

Strengths: Once again, Deuker slam dunks a novel. Mitch is a realistic and likable character, the football play-by-plays are enough to keep sports fans reading about a news reporter, and the mystery was top notch. Deuker is just one of the best yound adult novelists out there, and the best part of his work is that it is geared to older students without being in any way inappropriate for younger ones. Brilliant work. I'm glad he takes his time crafting superb novels-- I'll be waiting avidly for Swagger, the basketball novel he's writing now.

Weaknesses: None that I can see!


Wiles, Deborah. Countdown.
Franny has lots to worry about in 1962-- her uncle is trying to dig up the front yard for a bomb shelter, and occasionally shows up in his WWI gear; her sister is sneaking off; her mother is preoccupied; and the Cubans have missiles. Every time there is an air raid drill, it might be the end. A lot on your plate when you are 11. This highly atmospheric novel is accompanied by pictures, quotes, and vintage illustrations, which lend a scrap book feel to the story, which makes the history of the Cuban Missile Crisis a lot more accessible to students than a history book. This is the first in a trilogy.

Strengths: This made me feel like I lived through this time period; obviously, Wiles is drawing heavily on her personal experience.

Weaknesses: Might be a hard sell. I've been pitching history hard this year, and students are just not as interested in it as they should be.

3 comments:

Readingjunky said...

I love Carl Deuker books. They are so easy to sell to the guys. Thanks for mentioning SWAGGER. Didn't know he had some new coming out.

COUNTDOWN was fascinating, but I agree it's going to be a "hard sell."

RJ

Katie said...

Carl Deuker is fantastic! Gym Candy was my first from him and I'm anxious to get my hands on Swagger.

I have a feeling that you're right about Countdown being difficult to get students really engaged in. I actually think part of the problem is Franny's age; I would love to try this book with my middle schoolers, but fear they'll scoff at an 11-year-old protagonist. I wonder Jo Ellen as narrator would make the sell any easier?

Ms. Yingling said...

Having ALL the Deuker books is a MUST! And I think that the students would be much more interested in a book set in the 1960s with a rebellious teen narrator-- even think of The Wonder Years. That would be a much better spin on it!

Post a Comment

 
Template: Blog Designs by Sheila | Artwork: 123RF Stock Photos