Monday, February 10, 2014

MMGM- Secrets of the Book

18308645Fry, Erin. Secrets of the Book
4 February 2014, Two Lions
E ARC from

Spencer's mother makes him volunteer at a rest home, and Ed, the man he is visiting, gives him a Pandora's Book, which has the ability to bring famous people from the past to life. This is a bit of a problem with Socrates appears to Spence and his friend Gregor. Gregor is on the autism spectrum, so doesn't do well with loud noises or change in routine, but does fairly well talking to one of his idols. Of course, nothing is ever that simple-- a man shows up with Pandora's Other Book, looking for Spencer's help right around the time that Ed goes missing from his rest home. Ed has told his granddaughter Mel where to find Spencer, and she helps the boys figure out how to work the book. It turns out that the "other book" has the bad guys, and while the man in charge of the book is no saint (he turns out to be Al Capone), he has kept things safe, but can only continue to do so with Spencer's help. With Ed missing, and Gregor's dog taken hostage, can the kids return things to the way they should be without giving away the secrets?
Strengths: I love how Ms. Fry works cross country running into the book! There are some especially nice touches with Mel and Gregor's motivations for running that I liked, and the tiny bit of romance is good, too. Gregor's situation is portrayed realistically; in fact, it's one of the better portrayals of a child on the autism spectrum that I've read, and there are so many right now. The plot moves along nicely, and the characters from history remind me a little of Lubar's Flip, but with better action.
Weaknesses: Fry's Losing It was such a good novel that I was hoping for another realistic fiction book from her, since there are already so many fantasy books. No majr problems with this, just some quibbles-- Spencer's degenerative eye disease is mentioned at the beginning of the book, but then not addressed much later. There is one mention of track practice being canceled because of DRIZZLE-- is that what they do in California? (Yes, apparently it is!) Since this is more action/adventure than fantasy, I'll buy a copy.

18139989Plumeri, Arnauld and Bloz. In the Beginning: Dinosaurs #1
Papercutz, 7 January 2014
Review copy provided by publisher

This hardcover graphic novel introduces readers to lots of facts about dinosaurs. The information (strung together loosely by the narrator, cartoon archaeologist Indino Jones) has information on a variety of individual species, but also pages on eras, how fossiles are formed, dinosaur tracks and the disappearance of the dinosaurs, just to name a few.
Strengths: This is much better bound that other Papercutz books, so I will probably put this in my library. The information about dinosaurs is interspersed with funny anecdotes about them, so children interested in dinosaurs will not only get good information, but be amused as well.  I can see this being carried around constantly by some children who are really interested in dinosaurs, and would be a good gift for a first to third grader with those interests who is a strong reader.This is the first book in a series.
Weaknesses: I know that younger eyes don't have a problem, but the small dimension of the book ( 6.70 (w) x 9.10 (h) x 0.50 (d)) makes the font very small and hard to read. This is a translation of the French edition, and there are a few politically incorrect things that point to its European origins. (Fat, pushy wife, bullying dinosaurs.)

It's Marvelous Middle Grade Monday at Ramblings of a Wannabe Scribe and What Are You Reading? day at Teach Mentor Texts and Unleashing Readers. It's also Nonfiction Monday at Anastasia Suen's blog.


Holly Mueller said...

Secrets of the Book looks god! I'm always looking for more graphic novels - the kids LOVE them! Have a great reading week!

Janet, said...

Oh, I love the idea of having a book that has the ability to bring famous people from the past to life. But, I can see where it could create problems. Thanks for the review.

Barbara Watson said...

Losing It is in my reading pile right now. On this book of hers, however, I like that you say it's a good portrayal of a child with autism. And having that set in a fantasty sounds intriguing. said...

:) Thinking to myself "that'll be the day when I tire of fantasy" but perhaps I've read good books lately... Interesting to read your opinion on Secrets of the Book, perhaps it will be a "wait til it is in paperback" book for me... Have a wonderful reading week!

Michael G-G said...

Erin Fry's latest sounds like a blast. (The fact that Socrates is a kid's idol nearly made me spray my morning cuppa.) I'll have to look out for it.

Never been particularly big on dinosaurs in this house--don't ask me why, because I've tried. Now, pretending to be fairy tale characters--that's another story!

(If we cancelled cross country practice for drizzle, no one would ever run here!) said...

Very intriguing premise. I have not read anything by this author, so I may start here and work backwards. Thanks for featuring.

Tara Smith said...

Secrets of the Book does look interesting! I'm partial to time traveling books - because I would like to be able to do this!

Rosi said...

Thanks for telling me about Secret of the Books. It sounds great.

Deb said...

I am really looking forward to reading Erin Fry's latest. Glad to hear it is one you would buy!

Myra Garces Bacsal said...

Secrets of the Book sounds like something I'd enjoy! Will try to find it. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

Post a Comment

Template: Blog Designs by Sheila | Artwork: 123RF Stock Photos