Creepy and bloody

Gina and Dann Gershon's Campy Creepy Time looked very promising, with a picture of fangs in braces on the front cover and a description that included children sent to a summer camp where they are turned into monsters and then sold to space aliens. Unfortunately, the main character, Einstein P. Fleet, was pudgy and unlikable, and I thought that this would be a good ending for him. This also seemed strained and I couldn't suspend disbelief long enough to buy the premise. Perhaps a younger audience might appreciate this more, but middle school students rarely want humorous vampires and werewolves. There is a web site:
http://www.campcreepytime.com

It is blocked at my school as a "malicious site". No idea.

Also read Felix Salten's Bambi, from 1928. This is surprisingly readable, and it was interesting to find out about Faline's weak twin, Gobo, who spends a winter with humans and becomes desensitized to danger. That wasn't in the Disney version! The preface recommends this book for sportsmen, probably because there are a lot of bloody scenes in the book, complete with descriptions of how the animals feel about the devastation. This was a good book, but I am at a loss as to whom to recommend this. Not really animal lovers, since there is such devastation, but I'm not sure that the children who hunt want to read it, either. I'll leave this one as a serendipitous find.

Horses

Susan Saunders Kate's Secret Plan was somewhat uninspired. Set in 1926, a young girl wants to enter a horse racing/cattle cutting contest, but can't because girls aren't allowed to race. She wears her brothers clothes, wins the contest, and nothing more is really said. I don't think the issues would have resolved themselves this quickly. Poor line drawings do not help this book, which has been here seven years and only been checked out once.

Sam Savitt's Vicki and the Brown Mare, though published in 1976, was still pretty good. I loved the illustrations, which were done by the author. Vicki is trying to raise money by exercising neighbor's horses and breaking ones with bad habits. A lot of discussion about specific issues with horses, but a glossary is at the end. There are several other books in the series, but I unfortunately don't have them. I will keep this one for my students who love horses; they will enjoy it.

I was sad to see that Mr. Savitt passed away in 2000. More information about him can be found at:
http://www.samsavitt.com/about.html

Sebastian Rook's The Vampire Plagues

Some historical settings, some mystery, some adventure... and vampires!

Published only in paperback by Scholastic, these books will not appeal to the students who love New Moon and Vampire Kisses. Instead, students who like survival fiction, or books with chases and fighting will find Ben, Jack and Emily's adventures to save the world from the evil that is the vampire Camazotz enthralling.

The cheese factor is pretty high, (I can't say "Camazotz" without giggling) and the writing a bit uneven (some slang and situations that don't ring true for the time period), but the plots are well delineated and the story easy to follow. I read a review that accused this of being too gory and dark for children, and I would disagree with that. R.L. Stine has much more gore, and that completely unaplogetic. Here, children are saving the world from evil. Gore will be involved. Also, students are not bothered by things that are dark. In fact, I think that middle school has a huge developmental stage where children crave dark things. Perhaps it makes their own trauma in middle school seem not so bad.

A fine read. Do need to read all three books to get the whole story, and in order.

Dyan Sheldon

Big fan of Sheldon's. Her Sophie Pitt-Turnbull Discovers America and the sequel I Conquer Britain were such fun, and of course, Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen is a perennial favorite. I think there was even a movie.

What I like best is that the stories are, at first glance, pink and fluffy, but conceal hidden depths. This is especially true of Planet Janet. At first, these read like a less-annoying Louise Rennison (note: annoying only to people older than dirt, like me), with Janet, a British girl, keeping a diary of her attempt to explore the Dark Phase of her life, which she envisions as being full not only of black clothes, but jazz, yoga, and flirtations with vegetarianism. There are some deeper issues--parents divorce and date-- but in general, this is about Janet and her attempts at navigating her universe.

These have not circulated well, probably due to the very dark covers, but when I said to my 8th grade daughter "These are a bit like Louise Rennison", she practically yanked it out of my hands and ran to her room with it. These will NOW circulate well.

What struck me most was how funny these were for me as a parent. I don't know how funny my daughter will find Janet's trip to the grocery store-- she goes on and on how it takes forever and how she is doing her mother's job and yet will not be thanked (she's buying vegetarian food for herself). Even the beginning of the first book is a sly dig at the self-absorbtion of teenagers:

"Talk about self-centered! Me! Me! Me! Me! ME! That's all anybody in this house cares about. I was trying to have a normal conversation over supper (the way people do in films, etc.), not some Great Intellectual Discussion (I know my family's limits, believe me), when I realized that no one was listening to me. I stopped dead right in the middle of explaining about what happened at lunch (which was v dramatic and emotionally stressful), and no one so much as glanced my way. "

Will be interested to see if my daughter feels vaguely insulted. For more info on the v fab author, visit her web site at:

http://www.dyansheldon.co.uk/

Collins/Rideout The Black Sheep

Feel compelled to get a book that deals with reality shows, just to reflect the current trends? This would be the one. Much more readable and deeper than The Actual Real Reality of Jennifer James (6/19/2007), the only problem I have with this one is the cover-- it should be pink, to reflect the content. There is some whining by the main character, but that also reflects the current trends. In the end, Kendra learns a bit about being grateful, and expands her horizons. Is this great literature? No. Is this a good period piece about reality shows? Yes. It will circulate well.

Almost tempted by Veronica Bennet's Cassandra's Sister. It would be good to hand to students who want to read Jane Austen but can't get through it. Written in a similar, slow-paced period style, it tells the story of Jane Austen's early life and examines why she went on to write. Less intriguing but more appropriate than this author's Angelmonster, I'll recommend this, but from the public library.

Sebastian Rooks Vampire Plagues: London, 1850 was better than I remembered when I picked it up during Book Fair last year. Readers of New Moon are not going to like this one, but readers of Darren Shan might be tempted. More historical adventure than a vampire saga, I found myself intrigued by the end of the book and want to find out how the children fight off the vampire god with the silly name I can't remember. They go to Paris, and then Mexico, I believe. A little light on historical detail, or I would give it to students who need to read a historical Accelerated Reader book in November.

All Quiet on the Western Front

Erich Maria Remarque's 1929 novel of the First World War is hard to read. I don't understand why adolescent boys are so fond of this kind of fiction. It's brutal. Do they expect something of the "glory" of war? If so, they will not find it in this book. Remarque starts out with food, latrines, and boots. WWI was fought in the trenches, and was devastating to the soldiers. We see all of this-- the gas, the bombs, the illness. Written in German, it is an especially good lesson that the politics in a war don't matter that much to the people who lose the most. Soldiers are soldiers, no matter what nationality, and they are doing what they have been told to do. This is a haunting book, especially since it deals with a war fought 90 years ago. Apparently, we have not learned much in that time. The length of this book makes it suitable for stronger readers; the subject matter is delicately, if powerfully handled.

On the "Just didn't do anything for me" list:
Wollman's Switched: too much MySpace talk, implausible plot.
Casely's The Kissing Diary: no one asks for divorce books, generally too much information.
Chases' So Not the Drama: too many characters, too many plots, nothing pulled me in. HS?

That said, I did read about half of each one, since I had a girl not like Alanna: The First Adventure because it was boring. Once she read the entire first chapter, she was hooked. I can only like about 1/4 of the books I read-- it's all I can afford for the library!

Full Throttle and Photo Finish

The last two books in Matthew Reilly's Hover Car Racer series are just as fast paced as the first. The good and bad are clear cut, the main character embodies all the good characteristics we try to teach students (Never give up!), and there are lots of edge-of-your-seat races. I particularly liked the fact that Jason did not win every race, but he learned from the races that he lost. I think that reluctant readers will like these, but also avid readers who like Star Wars. I am trying the series out on my son to see what he thinks of it. Definitely looking for more from this author.

Did not, however, feel warmly toward Anna Feinberg's Number 8. There were some things to recommend it (OCD, troubled home life, mystery), but it started so slowly, and went back and forth in points of view, so didn't grab me. Perhaps for high school students?

The Hungry City Chronicles

Philip Reeve's four book series will make fantasy/sci fi fans very happy. These sizeable books are packed full of technical details as well as action, adventure and intrigue. Set in a futuristic society where cities move about, and large citie "eat" smaller ones, the main characters, Hester and Tom, are trying to live quiet lives and not succeeding.

I am not a great fantasy or sci fi fan, so these were a challenge for me. Better than Pullman's His Dark Materials series (involved the dreaded talking animals) but not as good as Pierce's Song of the Lioness, these were on par with Artemis Fowl. In fact, that's what they most reminded me of, because I couldn't find much likeable in any of the characters. Also, the whole society was so unpleasant that I really didn't want to spend time there. These are, however, very personal reasons. The writing is strong, and students will not have these objections. I would not recommend these to students who were not very avid fantasy fans, but for those students, these will be a good selection.

Weeding

It's so hard to get rid of books, especially when they are nice and new and haven't been read much, when my six copies of Stormbreaker are all held together with duct tape and I glue a two foot stack of books back together each week! (Or volunteers do! Thank you!)

There are reasons books stay pristine. Read one last night that had a dopey cover, silly title, and a description that didn't make me want to read it. I showed it to all three of my children and got the same reaction-- that slight, almost imperceptible nose wrinkle. Now, if I read a book and discover it has merits, by all means, I keep it. But this poor, unfortunate book didn't. So it is going to a better place where it will be happier. After 20 years, it should have gone out more than 8 times.

The publishers are doing a good job making cover art more timeless. Now if they could just make books where the pages don't separate entirely from the cover!

Survival Fiction/ Night of the Howling Dogs

Graham Salisbury's Eyes of the Emperor is his best work. Everything else pales in comparison to that, but he is always a solid, dependable author.

Night of the Howling Dogs is based on the true story of a scout troupe camping in Hawaii and getting caught up in an earthquake and subsequent tsunami in 1975. Salisbury visited the site with one of the survivors, which adds an immediacy to the story.

There is a lot of set up before the event-- there are rivalries and problems in the scout troupe, as well as description of the preparations for camping, and the camping before hand. What will sell the book, however, is the scenes involving the catastrophe. Just yesterday I had a student who wanted, very specifically, books about natural disasters, and I was able to send her off with Ruckman's Night of the Twisters and Cotton's Quake. This is a book to add to that.

Survival fiction has some die hard fans. Here are some additional titles. And yes, the list should probably be called "If you liked Hatchet". A quirky list with older titles.

Blackwood. Wild Timothy.
Carter. Between a Rock and a Hard Place.
Dygard. Wilderness Peril. River Danger.
George. My Side of the Mountain.
Gutman. Getting Air.
Hobbs. Downriver.
Houston. Frozen Fire.
Howard. The Ostrich Chase.
Kehret. Earthquake Terror.
Kelleher. Rescue!
Korman. Island, Dive, Everest (all series).
Marshall. Walkabout.
Mazer. Snowbound.
Napoli. Stones in Water.
Smith. Peak.
Mikaelson. Touching Spirit Bear.
Phleger. Pilot Down, Presumed Dead.
Roth. The Iceberg Hermit.

Crash Course by Reilly

Wow! Imagine that all transportation ran on the magnetic waves the earth puts out, and you could travel across the US in 90 minutes. Of course, there is a lot of interest in hover car racing, and we get to follow Jason to the International Racing School in this book. There, he finds all sorts of intrigue and danger as he learns to be a great racer.

Is this book cheesy? Oh, definitely! Did I care? Not at all. Jason's car is called the Argonaut and the cartoon pictures of the characters, especially La Bomba Romba are over the top, but the writing is solid. I loved it and I don't even like cars! I don't know that I have ever read a "penny dreadful" from years long past, but this was full of the action and adventure that I imagine those potboilers were. Now that I've read this, it will fly off the shelves as if all six magnetos are at 100% power. Photo Finish and Full Throttle are the other two in the series, and I am looking forward to them!

Ribbit! by Bender and Bender

Was skulking around the Barnes and Noble (our corporate sponsor-- parents, go there so they give our school free stuff!) waiting to enter a chance to win a school visit from Rick Riordan when I met the lovely Bender family, who were there to talk about their great new picture book, Ribbit!: Flip and See Who Froggie Can Be. (Don't get distracted by the game on the web site:)

http://www.harpercollinschildrens.com/harperchildrens/harperchildrensimages/game/ribbitgame.swf

Obviously, this is too young for the middle school, but if you have to give any gifts to younger children, they would find this endlessly fascinating. Even my 6th grade son was enthralled this morning. "Really? 3,000 combinations?" he said. He was still working on Cowboy Chad when I left. The illustrations are awesome-- bright, shiny and realistic but with that slickness that computer manipulation adds that makes you want to touch the picture to see if you can feel the lace. The authors are primarily photographic artists ( http://www.benderimaging.com/) and admitted that the words for the book came a little late.

That would be the only thing I would change. They did a credible job, but I'm a stickler for scansion and rhyme being perfect. It would also be especially clever if the second and fourth lines of each accompanying verse ended in an "ee" sound, so that even when you flipped the pages, the verses would rhyme. Something like "Cowboy Chad/with a smart goatee/rounds up steers/ and shouts 'Oooo-eee!" and "Gorgeous Greta/ so pert and pretty/ sings in the opera/ of a major city". It would be a lot of fun playing with the word and rhyme combinations, and would add another layer of silliness to a wonderful book.

It sounds like there may be other works in the offing, so I'll look forward to those with interest.

I bought a copy of Ribbit for my brother. Maybe now he will give me back The Ele-trich and the deck of Mixies cards.

Falling from Grace by Jane Godwin

The other day, I reinforced the idea that children should not take candy from strangers. Falling From Grace reminds them not to drink from open containers from strangers, and for goodness sake, don't go into their houses!

Of course, the stranger is the key to the whole mystery.

This book looks like a fairly simple tale of a girl who goes missing off the coast of Australia. I didn't expect so many plot twists. Told from alternating viewpoints of the girl's sister and a boy on vacation, it ends up being a compact and tightly written mystery involving a creepy man and a lot of misplaced suspicion. There are enough elements to make this appeal to students who like problem novels, and there's nothing that would make this inappropriate for any age. I don't want to give away the plot, and the clues start dropping early, but this will be a good addition to my mystery collection. The only problem is that this is set in Australia, and it does mention that in June, when the children are off for vacation, it's winter!

Mary E. Ryan's The Trouble with Perfect (1995) has not seen much circulation, but it should. Kyle is a good student, but too short for basketball. This wouldn't bother him so much, but his "deficits" are thrown in his face whenever his father gets drunk, which is often now that his job is in jeopardy. This is a realistic but somewhat sanitized account of how parents have problems too, and children are affected by them. The ending is a bit too neat, but it's better to have a positive example of obtaining help and coping for children who might be in the same situation. I have a couple of readers who will both enjoy and benefit from this title.

And yes, I'm about done with all of the "R" authors but Philip Reeve. I'm going to try to take the Hungry City Chronicles home for Thanksgiving and read them all.

Almost but not quite.

Always a bummer when books sound good but don't quite fit what I need.

David Klass's Firestorm, the first in the triology, has the same breathless, downhill sort of narrative voice that made You Don't Know Me so compelling to read. Lots of action helped speed along the beginning. However, there was too much sexuality for middle school; it was well handled and not graphic, but just too much information for my students. Also, after a while I just wanted to know what the heck was going on. Why was Jack being chased? This would be a good choice for high school, and the environmental portion is wonderful, but I don't see it being a successful read at this age.

Loved Katherine Hall Page's Club Meds. The idea that a student continuing to come to terms with his disorder and medication would be bullied into giving it up to a student who is dealing Ritalin is great, but there were too many gratuitous f-bombs and a lot of sexuality as well. Again, great for high school.

Conor Kostick's Epic sounded good in the description-- futuristic society where your entire life is predicated on how well you do in a computer game-- but somehow didn't interest me. The students who want books about computer gaming don't have very long attention spans. A better choice would be Rune Michaels' Genesis Alpha.

Brandon Mull's Candy Shop War

Don't take candy from strangers.

Even strangers who run shops. Especially if the strangers ask you to do increasingly illegal errands for them while they are drugging the authority figures in your life with white fudge. Even if the candy they give you is magic and makes you fly or makes your enemies sprout fur, DON'T TAKE THE CANDY.

This book creeped me out. So students will love it.

Like Mull's Fablehaven, the children are in control of a lot, there is action and adventure, as well as some interesting magic.

I'm just disturbed. I was expecting something like Mrs. Piggle-wiggle. This is far more complex and involves a lot of evil. Evil with a smile. This objection is purely because I am an adult; I'm curious to see what the students think!

Rrrrrrrr we there yet?

My trek through the stacks continues! Still held up at Philip Reeve's Hungry City Chronicles. 

 Richter, Hans Peter. Friedrich. 1961. In flashback format, we follow the life of Friedrich, a young Jewish boy, through the eyes of his best friend and neighbor, a Gentile. We are shown how everyday occurrences change over time and become more and more difficult for Friedrich's family. An informative time line is included at the end of this book. This is a slow-paced and introspective work; the Holocaust is of great interest to many 8th graders, and is studied as part of the language arts curriculum. This work is better suited to students who have started with other, more immediately engaging titles such as Moskin's I am Rosemarie, Orlev's The Man from the Other Side or Spinelli's Milkweed. 

Robinet, Harriette Gillem. If you please, President Lincoln. 1995 This book is hampered by the title: if it were called Survivor: Ile a Vache it would circulate more. Set just before the Civil War, this story follows Moses, a house slave of a Catholic priest. After escaping, he ends up on a ship of slaves being sent to an island near Haiti to set up a colony and grow cotton. The slaves are ill treated on the ship and in no condition to fair well on the island; smallpox and starvation run rampant. Eventually, the slaves are retrieved and taken back to the US, where Moses and an older man make a life for themselves. An afternote describes how President Lincoln at first thought that relocating freed slaves would be a good idea, but how he changed his mind. It was too late for the group Moses was with, and many people died. Written in a story telling style, this book will appeal to students who like adventure fiction and need to read something historical.

 Ruckman, Ivy. Night of the Twisters. 1984. Based on an actual event in Grand Island, Nebraska in 1980 (my family had friends who lost their house at this time), this follows two boys who are left alone right before the twisters hit. A short and easy-to-read book (which, oddly enough, has the rather high Accelerated Reader level of 6.9 assigned to it!), this story is suspenseful and realistic. Dan and his friend must take care of Dan's infant brother while surviving the storm, which was quite devastating. The details make the danger immediate, but all turns out well in the end. This is used in the 6th grade as a class novel. A good choice, since it should appeal to most children. 

 Ruby, Lois. Skin Deep. 1994. There aren't many books about students involved with Neonazi groups, and this one is well balanced. We can understand why Dan gets involved with a local skin head group; he is recently relocated, living in a small aparment with his mother and two sisters, and unable to find a job or join the swim team because of Affirmative Action. This is a bit overdone, but helps to make the point. It was interesting how Dan first starts dressing the part, and then actually joins a group involved in hate crimes, because that is one thing antidrug programs teach parents-- before students get involved in behaviors, they often dress the part. Walking a very fine line, Ruby shows how Dan goes along with the group until they threaten someone he knows and likes, and he then understands that hating others is not the way to improve his own situation. A very tricky subject, and adroitly handled. 

 Also read Jacqueline Wilson's Candyfloss. This is a book for younger students than I thought, but the 6th graders who think they want to read Rennison's Georgia Nicolson books but aren't ready for them will enjoy it. Floss's mother and stepfather are relocated to Australia for six months and she decides to stay in England with her father, who runs a chip shop. Things are not going well for her father, and there are many problems that arise while she is staying with him. Cathy Cassidy's fans will also find this enjoyable-- a pleasant mix of problems with humor. Do not see Gregory Maguire's What-the-Dickens meeting any needs in my collection, but since my daughter is a HUGE fan of Wicked, I am having her read the book to see if it is something she likes.

National Book Award Finalists

Because I know that I am not going to discuss these books (having decided they don't fit the needs of my library, not because of my extreme prejudice against award winners. Really.), if you follow this sort of thing, I defer to Leila Roy at Bookshelves of Doom:

http://bookshelvesofdoom.blogs.com/bookshelves_of_doom/2007/10/national-book-a.html

Blood Brothers by Harazin

Don't know how I missed commenting on this one, but Ronni gives a perfect description, and I agree with her completely!
http://ronnisreviews.blogspot.com/2007/08/blood-brothers-sa-harazin.html

There are a lot of new CSI type books, and while it alarms me that students are watching these shows, the books are well done and not nearly hard to deal with. Alane Ferguson's The Christopher Killer series is wonderfully done. Boys who like Blood Brothers may also like Morgenroth's Jude, which is a little grittier than I usually like, but for a longer book has enticed a lot of reluctant readers.

Thanks, Ronni! Tell your friend this is circulating really well at my library!

The author himself tags this as "for readers 14 and up".
http://saharazin.com/

Meyer, Gantos and Fredericks

The idea of being a princess mesmerizes middle school girls, and the story of Caterina de' Medici, as told by Carolyn Meyer in Duchessina is full of the grandeur of royalty, and well as the danger. When her parents died shortly after her birth, Caterina was forced to rely on relatives for her care, and was used by many of them to achieve political ends. Widespread bad feelings for other members of her family put her in constant danger, and she is not safe even while staying with nuns at a convent. Eventually forced into marriage with a man who does not love her, Caterina tries to find happiness for herself despite her unpleasant circumstances. Historical notes inform us that Caterina is remembered historically as something of a villain, but this book (part of the Young Royals series that also includes Patience Princess Catherine, Doomed Queen Anne, Mary, Bloody Mary and Beware, Princess Elizabeth) offers a detailed look at what daily life was like for a spirited young woman growing up in a difficult time. These books are a great way to lure girls into historical fiction.

Reading Jack Gantos' I am Not Joey Pigza is not like a plastic slide, "kid-friendly, but also kid-boring" (Page 9). It is definitely more akin to the metal kind that Joey likes to grease with Wesson oil and slide down. Like this stunt, the ride is frenetic and thrilling, but ultimately painful. Joey Pigza has never led an ideal life, but this story is sadder than the other, and hits dead center at the number one concern students have-- establishing personal identity. His father, who abandoned him at birth, shows up with a new identity. His mother is thrilled with the new stability that the father offers and agrees happily with all of the changes-- new names, a new house, and a new source of income. Joey's dad, however, soon shows his accustomed behavior and even Joey realizes that constant playing and lack of responsibility doesn't lead to a good outcome. Fans of this series will enjoy this books for its frenetic style and amusing anecdotes, but it is an ultimately disturbing book with an unsettling ending. Joey Pigza Swallowed the Key is read as a class novel in our school, and readers of this new title would benefit from discussing this book and thinking about the issues involved with some guidance.

Mariah Fredericks' The True Meaning of Cleavage is a book whose excellent and thought-provoking content overrode the provocative cover, but her new Love: In the Cards didn't grab me. There was a lot going on, and I somehow felt that I had come in in the middle of the story and never really caught up. It was hard to keep up with the large cast of characters, and I could not become emotionally invested in the main character. Still, the cover is graphically pleasing, and the idea of using Tarot cards to predict romantic outcomes will appeal to the insatiable readers of "pink" books. There are two more books planned in this series, but I may pass.

Thanks to Anne Levy at http://www.bookbuds.net for providing some tips for bloggers. I will try to improve my posts. My real audience is students and parents who are looking for something good to read, but I would like to be a resource for librarians who don't have time to read books but want to know if something is worth purchasing. I'll try to write in book talk format, but that is hard when I don't intend to purchase a book because I didn't like it. I treat my school library very much like a personal collection, and I find that if I don't like a book it frequently doesn't get as much use. Since funds are limited, I do have to purchase carefully, and this often means finding reasons NOT to buy books.

Gutman, Cabot and Heldring

Have to classify Dan Gutman's Getting Air as a fantasy. Any child who does not like this is dead inside and I can't help. Four children going to see a skateboarding competition (oddly enough without parents) and a plane full of ladies going to a knitting convention are highjacked by terrorists of some unspecified fanatical religious bent. The children overcome the highjackers and crash the plane. They survive with the help of one of the ladies and the beautiful flight attendant. When they are rescued (after turning the wreckage into a half pipe), they find out the terrorists wanted to crash into the US Capitol building, so are rewarded with all sorts of product sponsorships and tv appearances.

Hoaky? Yes. Will the children love it? Yes. Even the cover is great! Mr. Gutman needs to drop whatever he is doing IMMEDIATELY and write a series of skateboarding books. Right now. I think I can trust him to go light on the moral lesson that most skateboarding books want to throw in.

Meg Cabot's Pants on Fire was okay. After a while, it started to remind me of How to be Popular. Good stuff, and I enjoyed it, but it was fluffier than usual. Luckily, even though much kissing was involved, it wasn't like Ready or Not, and I don't feel bad having it on the shelves. Note to publishers: Please stop putting pictures of girl's with bare stomachs on the covers. In 15 years it will just look stupid.

Newcover Thatcher Heldring has a strong start in Toby Wheeler, 8th Grade Benchwarmer. Almost perfect sports novel. Right length, action well-balanced with life problems, realistic rivalry, and even the triumphant ending was believable. I liked the idea of a self-proclaimed "gym rat" joining a team and having a few problems fitting in. Mr. Heldring, hurry up and write some more. Stick mainly to basketball and football, maybe some skateboarding. Feel free to follow Toby into high school. Perhaps Toby Wheeler, 9th Grade ...well, that shows you how little I know about sports. But it would be easy to tell students what was next in the series! There are never enough sports books for middle school boys!