It's Marvelous Middle Grade Monday at Always in the Middle and #IMWAYR day at Teach Mentor Texts and Unleashing Readers. It's also Nonfiction Monday.
Public library copy
Strengths: Ethel was one of the best characters I've read in a while. Her life isn't perfect, but she has a great attitude and makes the best of her. Her grandmother is WONDERFUL-- I love her distinctions between "common" and "vulgar", and all of the manners that she has taught Ethel. Boyd is fun, the British setting is very vivid, and even Ethel's great-grandmother at the nursing home has a good turn. Even though this is a bit on the long side (422 pages), it was a pleasant, quick read.
Weaknesses: Things got a little fraught near the end of the book; I had to put it down for a bit near the end when some decidedly unpleasant things occurred. Did that make the story better? Debating.
What I really think: Definitely purchasing, although this will not be a particularly popular title, since very British books seem to confuse many of my children. For selected readers, however, this will be a fun read, and I'll hopefully have it available in the library for many years.
Wow, sounds like a very unique storyline that will be quite enticing to middle graders! My initial concern would be the 422 pages, as you pointed out. But there are a great many readers at that age who prefer longer works. Do you happen to know if this a re-published title? Thanks for sharing, I'm happy to learn of this one!
ReplyDeleteI can only imagine how many teens with acne would like to be invisible. I like that this topic is covered in a lighthearted manner, with a bit of magical realism.
ReplyDeleteWow. This sounds like nothing else I've heard of. Very original. I'm reading a British book right now and the language can be off-putting. (I'm still trying to figure out what "scratching" are -- something one would eat in a bar.) I think I would like the book. Thanks for the review.
ReplyDelete